A mini-review on combinatorial solutions to the Marcus-Lushnikov irreversible aggregation

TL;DR

This review discusses a combinatorial framework for analyzing irreversible aggregation systems, highlighting its derivation, extensions to various kernels, and applications to aerosol and planetesimal formation, offering new analytical tools and insights.

Contribution

It introduces a combinatorial approach to aggregation, providing explicit formulas and recursive methods for different kernels, expanding beyond classical models.

Findings

Derived combinatorial expressions for cluster distributions with the constant kernel

Extended methods to additive, product, linear-chain, and condensation kernels

Validated predictions against numerical simulations in aerosol and planetesimal formation

Abstract

Over the past decade, a combinatorial framework for discrete, finite, and irreversibly aggregating systems has emerged. This work reviews its progress, practical applications, and limitations. We outline the approach's assumptions and foundations, based on direct enumeration of system states, contrasting with classical Smoluchowski and Marcus-Lushnikov methods. Using the constant kernel as an example, we derive combinatorial expressions for the average number of clusters of a given size and their standard deviation, and present the complete probability distribution for cluster counts. The method is then extended to several kernels (additive, product, linear-chain, condensation) by explicitly enumerating ways to form clusters of a given size. For general kernels, approximate solutions are obtained via recursive expressions, enabling predictions without explicit solutions. Applications to aerosol growth and planetesimal formation are demonstrated, with comparisons to numerical results. We summarize issues of validity and precision and propose open problems. The appendix includes partial Bell polynomials, generating functions, Lagrange inversion, potential applications, and links between combinatorial and scaling solutions of the Smoluchowski equation.