TriDF: Evaluating Perception, Detection, and Hallucination for Interpretable DeepFake Detection

TL;DR

TriDF is a comprehensive benchmark for interpretable DeepFake detection that evaluates perception, detection, and hallucination across multiple media types, aiming to improve trustworthy synthetic media identification.

Contribution

Introduces TriDF, a new benchmark dataset and evaluation framework for assessing interpretability and reliability of DeepFake detection models across modalities.

Findings

Perception ability is crucial for accurate detection.

Hallucination can significantly impair explanation reliability.

State-of-the-art models show interdependence of perception, detection, and hallucination.

Abstract

Advances in generative modeling have made it increasingly easy to fabricate realistic portrayals of individuals, creating serious risks for security, communication, and public trust. Detecting such person-driven manipulations requires systems that not only distinguish altered content from authentic media but also provide clear and reliable reasoning. In this paper, we introduce TriDF, a comprehensive benchmark for interpretable DeepFake detection. TriDF contains high-quality forgeries from advanced synthesis models, covering 16 DeepFake types across image, video, and audio modalities. The benchmark evaluates three key aspects: Perception, which measures the ability of a model to identify fine-grained manipulation artifacts using human-annotated evidence; Detection, which assesses classification performance across diverse forgery families and generators; and Hallucination, which quantifies the reliability of model-generated explanations. Experiments on state-of-the-art multimodal large language models show that accurate perception is essential for reliable detection, but hallucination can severely disrupt decision-making, revealing the interdependence of these three aspects. TriDF provides a unified framework for understanding the interaction between detection accuracy, evidence identification, and explanation reliability, offering a foundation for building trustworthy systems that address real-world synthetic media threats.