A window for water-hydrogen demixing on warm metal-rich sub-Neptunes

TL;DR

This study introduces ATHENAIA, a framework to assess water-hydrogen demixing in warm sub-Neptunes, revealing that demixing can occur at higher temperatures and metallicities than previously thought, affecting interior composition models.

Contribution

The paper presents ATHENAIA, a novel inference framework combining atmospheric and interior models to evaluate water-hydrogen demixing in warm sub-Neptunes, challenging existing assumptions.

Findings

Demixing can occur at temperatures of 330-450 K in metal-rich sub-Neptunes.

Higher metallicity and mass increase the likelihood of demixing.

Considering greenhouse effects and adiabatic gradients broadens the range of possible interior states.

Abstract

Sub-Neptunes represent the largest exoplanet demographic, yet their bulk compositions remain poorly understood. Recent studies suggested that only very cold planets, such as Uranus and Neptune, could experience stratification of volatiles in their envelopes. Transiting warm sub-Neptunes, with $10^3$ to $10^4$ times more stellar irradiation, were therefore believed to have fully-miscible compositions. Here, we present ATHENAIA, an interior-atmosphere composition inference framework we leverage to assess the potential for water-hydrogen demixing on warm sub-Neptunes and for the 350 K planet TOI-270 d as a case study, using radiative-convective atmosphere models coupled to interior models. We find that the higher temperatures at which hydrogen and water demix in water-rich environments open a window for demixing on sub-Neptunes with bulk envelope metallicities of $\sim 150$ to $700\times$ solar, compatible with TOI-270 d. Demixing is easier to achieve on more massive and colder planets, but still broadly affects warm ($\simeq $330 to 450 K) metal-rich sub-Neptunes. Therefore, combining atmosphere metallicities with models of fully-miscible envelopes may lead to underestimated bulk envelope metallicities and mass fractions. Further, we find that considering the increased greenhouse effect in metal-rich atmospheres in concert with the composition-dependent adiabatic gradient in the convective envelope increases the range of compositions under which molten mantle conditions should be expected on sub-Neptunes. This work encourages a reconsideration of the current paradigm for linking sub-Neptune atmospheres to their interiors and motivates evolutionary modeling describing the onset of metallicity gradients in sub-Neptune envelopes.