TL;DR
This paper introduces CoLOR, a novel method for open-set recognition that remains effective even when the background distribution shifts, supported by theoretical guarantees and extensive empirical validation.
Contribution
The paper develops CoLOR, a scalable and robust approach with provable guarantees for open-set recognition under background distribution shift, outperforming existing methods.
Findings
CoLOR outperforms baseline methods under background shift.
Theoretical guarantees are provided for CoLOR's effectiveness.
Performance is influenced by the size of the novel class.
Abstract
As we deploy machine learning systems in the real world, a core challenge is to maintain a model that is performant even as the data shifts. Such shifts can take many forms: new classes may emerge that were absent during training, a problem known as open-set recognition, and the distribution of known categories may change. Guarantees on open-set recognition are mostly derived under the assumption that the distribution of known classes, which we call the background distribution, is fixed. In this paper we develop CoLOR, a method that is guaranteed to solve open-set recognition even in the challenging case where the background distribution shifts. We prove that the method works under benign assumptions that the novel class is separable from the non-novel classes, and provide theoretical guarantees that it outperforms a representative baseline in a simplified overparameterized setting. We…
Peer Reviews
Decision·Submitted to ICLR 2025
- identification and formalization of understudied OSDA challenges - Specific attention to challenging real-world scenarios like low-proportion novel classes
- All datasets are semi-synthetic. It would be interesting if authors can show results on practical datasets. - While the problem addressed is quite interesting theoretically, practical relevance is unclear. As mentioned above, the paper may benefit from including results on datasets which inherently satisfy the problem discussed in the paper - The paper may also benefit from discussing how using stronger CLIP models alters the behavior of the baselines and the proposed method.
- Strong theoretical foundation with formal analysis of background shift in OSDA, including necessary/sufficient conditions and limitations of existing approaches. - Comprehensive empirical evaluation across multiple modalities (images and text) and varying novel class ratios.
- While background shift is justified with potential applications in medical imaging (e.g., identifying known and novel tumor cells), this application is not addressed in the experiments. Including other real-world cases would strengthen the relevance of background shift beyond this initial mention. - The abstract could be improved by defining “background shift” and avoiding vague phrases like "principled methods." - The claim “we observe that existing OSDA methods are not robust to the distri
1. Introducing background shift in OSDA community is interesting and novel. 2. Proposed method is based on theoretical evidence. 3. Experiments are well structured to verify the effectiveness of background shift.
1. This work has limited novelty and originality since it relies heavily on [1], which provide theoretical analysis of OOD novel category detection. Lemma 1 and Theorem 1 in this manuscript are quite similar claim with Proposition 3.1 and Theorem 4.3 in [1] though they focus different task. Furthermore, it is unclear that Theorem 1 in this manuscript can be easily extended on OSDA since there is no proof in the manuscript and supplementary material. 2. Proposed method is rather incremental. I t
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsDomain Adaptation and Few-Shot Learning · Face recognition and analysis · Face and Expression Recognition
