Entanglement gain in supercatalytic state transformations

TL;DR

This paper investigates supercatalytic entanglement gain in quantum state transformations, introducing a measure for its performance, analyzing when maximal gain is achievable, and exploring minimal entanglement scenarios.

Contribution

It introduces a quantitative figure of merit for supercatalytic entanglement gain and analyzes conditions for achieving maximal or near-maximal gain in state transformations.

Findings

Maximal entanglement gain can be achieved with appropriately chosen catalysts.

Many catalytic transformations are not fully supercatalyzable, with zero entanglement gain possible.

Minimal supercatalysis can approach maximal gain without requiring highly entangled catalysts.

Abstract

Catalysis refers to the possibility of performing an otherwise impossible local state transformation by sharing an additional state, i.e. a catalyst, which is returned at the end of the protocol. There is a stronger version, known as supercatalysis, in which the borrowed catalyst is returned in an enhanced form, i.e. more entangled. However, this phenomenon has remained little explored. In this work we introduce the supercatalytic entanglement gain as a figure of merit taking values in [0,1] that quantifies the performance of the protocol (with 0 corresponding to the standard case of catalysis and 1 representing the maximal possible gain) and we study in which cases it can be greater than zero and which strategies can maximize it. While it turns out that every catalytic transformation can be implemented in a supercatalytic fashion with entanglement gain equal to 1 if the state that is borrowed is chosen appropriately, other choices can make the gain strictly less than 1 and even 0. In fact, we prove that a large class of catalytic transformations are not fully supercatalyzable, i.e. there is at least one choice of catalyst for which the entanglement gain vanishes. On the other hand, the construction that shows that supercatalysis is always possible with maximal gain uses artificially highly entangled catalysts. For this reason, we also study minimal supercatalysis, where the entanglement content of the borrowed state is constrained in a precise and natural way. While we consider a scenario where we prove it is impossible to have entanglement gain equal to 1 in this case, we show that there exist minimal supercatalytic transformations with gain as close to 1 as desired. We also explore several examples and observe that, although choosing a catalyst with the least possible entanglement is often an optimal strategy for minimal supercatalysis, this is not necessarily always the case.