Dark Matter-Dark Radiation Interactions and the Hubble Tension

TL;DR

This paper investigates dark matter-dark radiation interaction models as a solution to the Hubble tension, analyzing their fit to cosmological data and how they reduce the discrepancy in Hubble constant measurements.

Contribution

It evaluates a general class of dark matter-dark radiation interaction models, identifying the most effective decoupling scenarios for alleviating the Hubble tension.

Findings

All three benchmark scenarios reduce the Hubble tension significantly.

Exponential decoupling scenario is most preferred among the models.

Including ACT DR6 data worsens the fit and limits the reduction of tension.

Abstract

Models in which a subcomponent of dark matter interacts with dark radiation have been proposed as a solution to the Hubble tension. In this framework, the interacting subcomponent of dark matter is in thermal equilibrium with the dark radiation in the early universe, but decouples from it around the time of matter-radiation equality. We study this general class of models and evaluate the quality of fit to recent cosmological data on the cosmic microwave background (from Planck 2018 and ACT DR6), baryon acoustic oscillations, large-scale structure, supernovae type Ia, and Cepheid variables. We focus on three benchmark scenarios that differ in the rate at which the dark matter decouples from the dark radiation, resulting in different patterns of dark acoustic oscillations. Fitting without ACT DR6 data, we find that all three scenarios significantly reduce the Hubble tension relative to $\Lambda$CDM, with an exponentially fast decoupling being the most preferred. The tension is reduced to less than $2 \, \sigma$ in fits that don't include the SH0ES collaboration results as part of the data and to less than $1 \, \sigma$ when these are included. When ACT DR6 data is included, the fit is significantly worsened. We find that the largest $H_0$ value at the $95 \%$ confidence region is $70.1$ km/s/Mpc without the SH0ES data, leading to only a mild reduction in the tension. This increases to $72.5$ km/s/Mpc, corresponding to a reduction in the tension to less than $3 \, \sigma$, if the SH0ES results are included in the fit.