Utilizing subgroup information in random-effects meta-analysis of few studies

TL;DR

This paper introduces a subgroup-based inference method for random-effects meta-analysis, improving small-sample performance when few studies are available, by synthesizing data at the subgroup level and using tailored heterogeneity estimators.

Contribution

It proposes a novel subgroup-level synthesis approach with new heterogeneity estimators, enhancing accuracy and interval precision in small-sample meta-analyses.

Findings

Improved heterogeneity estimation in small-sample settings.

More accurate confidence intervals with t-quantile based methods.

Effective application demonstrated through real data examples.

Abstract

Random-effects meta-analyses are widely used for evidence synthesis in medical research. However, conventional methods based on large-sample approximations often exhibit poor performance in case of very few studies (e.g., 2 to 4), which is very common in practice. Existing methods aiming to improve small-sample performance either still suffer from poor estimates of heterogeneity or result in very wide confidence intervals. Motivated by meta-analyses evaluating surrogate outcomes, where units nested within a trial are often exploited when the number of trials is small, we propose an inference approach based on a common-effect estimator synthesizing data from the subgroup-level instead of the study-level. Two DerSimonian-Laird type heterogeneity estimators are derived using the subgroup-level data, and are incorporated into the Henmi-Copas type variance to adequately reflect variance components. We considered t-quantile based intervals to account for small-sample properties and used flexible degrees of freedom to reduce interval lengths. A comprehensive simulation is conducted to study the performance of our methods depending on various magnitudes of subgroup effects as well as subgroup prevalences. Some general recommendations are provided on how to select the subgroups, and methods are illustrated using two example applications.