Temporal Realism Evaluation of Generated Videos Using Compressed-Domain Motion Vectors

TL;DR

This paper proposes a scalable, compressed-domain motion vector-based framework to evaluate the temporal realism of generated videos, revealing motion discrepancies and improving discrimination accuracy.

Contribution

It introduces a novel, lightweight method using compressed video motion vectors for temporal realism assessment and enhances discriminative models with MV-based fusion techniques.

Findings

Motion vectors reveal systematic motion discrepancies in generated videos.

MV-based features improve real-vs-generated classification accuracy.

Compressed-domain MVs effectively diagnose motion defects in generative videos.

Abstract

Temporal realism remains a central weakness of current generative video models, as most evaluation metrics prioritize spatial appearance and offer limited sensitivity to motion. We introduce a scalable, model-agnostic framework that assesses temporal behavior using motion vectors (MVs) extracted directly from compressed video streams. Codec-generated MVs from standards such as H.264 and HEVC provide lightweight, resolution-consistent descriptors of motion dynamics. We quantify realism by computing Kullback-Leibler, Jensen-Shannon, and Wasserstein divergences between MV statistics of real and generated videos. Experiments on the GenVidBench dataset containing videos from eight state-of-the-art generators reveal systematic discrepancies from real motion: entropy-based divergences rank Pika and SVD as closest to real videos, MV-sum statistics favor VC2 and Text2Video-Zero, and CogVideo shows the largest deviations across both measures. Visualizations of MV fields and class-conditional motion heatmaps further reveal center bias, sparse and piecewise constant flows, and grid-like artifacts that frame-level metrics do not capture. Beyond evaluation, we investigate MV-RGB fusion through channel concatenation, cross-attention, joint embedding, and a motion-aware fusion module. Incorporating MVs improves downstream classification across ResNet, I3D, and TSN backbones, with ResNet-18 and ResNet-34 reaching up to 97.4% accuracy and I3D achieving 99.0% accuracy on real-versus-generated discrimination. These findings demonstrate that compressed-domain MVs provide an effective temporal signal for diagnosing motion defects in generative videos and for strengthening temporal reasoning in discriminative models. The implementation is available at: https://github.com/KurbanIntelligenceLab/Motion-Vector-Learning