Synthetic JWST galaxy images in the TNG50 simulation - I. Model validation and comparison to observations

TL;DR

This study creates realistic synthetic JWST galaxy images from the TNG50 simulation to evaluate the accuracy of SED fitting in recovering galaxy properties at high redshift, comparing results with actual observations.

Contribution

It introduces a novel method for generating dust-aware synthetic JWST observations from TNG50, enabling validation of galaxy property recovery techniques against real data.

Findings

Photometric redshifts are accurately recovered at z ≤ 5.

Stellar masses are systematically underestimated, especially at high masses.

Simulated galaxy colours broadly match observed trends but show slight deviations.

Abstract

We use the TNG50 cosmological simulation and three-dimensional radiative transfer post-processing to generate dust-aware synthetic observations of galaxies at $ 3 \leq z \leq 6 $ and $ \log_{10}(M_\ast/\mathrm{M}_\odot) \geq 8.5 $, tailored to match the depth and resolution of current deep JWST surveys (NGDEEP and JADES). We analyse the performance of spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting on the simulated sample, focusing on the recovery of photometric redshift and stellar mass. At $ z \leq 5 $, we find that 90 per cent of redshifts are recovered within $ \pm0.2 $, but performance declines at $ z = 6 $. Stellar masses are generally well-recovered within a factor of 2, but are systematically underestimated regardless of redshift, a trend that is more pronounced at the high-mass end $ ( \log_{10}(M_\ast/\mathrm{M}_\odot) \geq 10 ) $. In addition, we study the observer-frame colours of galaxies in this redshift range as well as the SED-inferred $UVJ$ diagram. We find that TNG50 galaxies broadly follow the tendencies marked by observations, but tend to be slightly redder at lower masses and bluer at higher masses, regardless of redshift. Finally, using a colour-based definition of quiescence, we determine the fraction of quiescent galaxies as a function of stellar mass at $ 3 \leq z \leq 6 $, which we find to be broadly consistent with observations.