Revisiting the unification of tidal disruption events with polarimetry

TL;DR

This study uses optical polarimetry of 19 tidal disruption events to test a unification model, revealing that most events fit the model but some show deviations, indicating diverse behaviors.

Contribution

It provides the first comprehensive polarimetric analysis of TDEs to constrain their geometry and emission processes, testing and refining the unification scenario.

Findings

Most non-relativistic TDEs fit the unification model.

Optical polarisation levels are typically 1-2%, often below 6%.

Polarisation evolution suggests rapidly changing, asymmetric photospheres.

Abstract

Tidal disruptions of stars by supermassive black holes produce multi-wavelength emission, of which the optical emission is of ambiguous origin. A unification scenario of tidal disruption events (TDEs) has been proposed to explain the different classes of X-ray and optically selected events by introducing a dependence on the viewing angle and geometry. This work aims to test the unification scenario among optically bright TDEs using polarimetry. By studying the optical linear polarisation of 19 TDEs (of which 9 newly analysed in this work), we place constraints on their photosphere geometry, inclination, and the emission process responsible for the optical radiation. We study how these properties correlate with the relative X-ray brightness. We find that 14/16 non-relativistic events can be accommodated by the unification model. Continuum polarisation levels of optical TDEs lie most often in the range P ~ 1-2% (13 events), and for all except one event, remain below 6%. For those optical TDEs that have multi-epoch polarimetry, the continuum polarisation decreases after peak light for 5/10 events, increases for 3/10 events, and stays nearly constant for 2/10 events. When observed after +70 days (7/16 events), they become consistent with P = 0% within uncertainties (5/7 events). This implies the photosphere geometries of TDEs are at least initially asymmetric and evolve rapidly which, if tracing the formation of the accretion disk, suggests efficient circularisation. The polarisation signatures of emission lines of 7 TDEs directly support a scenario in which optical light is reprocessed in an electron-scattering photosphere. [...] However, a subset of events deviates from the unification model to some extent, suggesting this model may not fully capture the diverse behaviour of TDEs. Multi-epoch polarimetry plays a key role in understanding the evolution and emission mechanisms of TDEs.