Demystifying Cookie Sharing Risks in WebView-based Mobile App-in-app Ecosystems

TL;DR

This paper uncovers a new vulnerability called Cross Mini-program Cookie Sharing (CMCS) in web-view based mini-programs within super-apps, demonstrating widespread risks and proposing a static analysis tool for detection.

Contribution

It introduces the CMCS vulnerability, analyzes its prevalence across major platforms, and develops MiCoScan, a static analysis tool for large-scale detection of affected mini-programs.

Findings

All four analyzed platforms are affected by CMCS.

Large-scale analysis found 45,448 clusters sharing web-view domains.

Identified 7,965 instances of privileged data transmission.

Abstract

Mini-programs, an emerging mobile application paradigm within super-apps, offer a seamless and installation-free experience. However, the adoption of the web-view component has disrupted their isolation mechanisms, exposing new attack surfaces and vulnerabilities. In this paper, we introduce a novel vulnerability called Cross Mini-program Cookie Sharing (CMCS), which arises from the shared web-view environment across mini-programs. This vulnerability allows unauthorized data exchange across mini-programs by enabling one mini-program to access cookies set by another within the same web-view context, violating isolation principles. As a preliminary step, we analyzed the web-view mechanisms of four major platforms, including WeChat, AliPay, TikTok, and Baidu, and found that all of them are affected by CMCS vulnerabilities. Furthermore, we demonstrate the collusion attack enabled by CMCS, where privileged mini-programs exfiltrate sensitive user data via cookies accessible to unprivileged mini-programs. To measure the impact of collusion attacks enabled by CMCS vulnerabilities in the wild, we developed MiCoScan, a static analysis tool that detects mini-programs affected by CMCS vulnerabilities. MiCoScan employs web-view context modeling to identify clusters of mini-programs sharing the same web-view domain and cross-webview data flow analysis to detect sensitive data transmissions to/from web-views. Using MiCoScan, we conducted a large-scale analysis of 351,483 mini-programs, identifying 45,448 clusters sharing web-view domains, 7,965 instances of privileged data transmission, and 9,877 mini-programs vulnerable to collusion attacks. Our findings highlight the widespread prevalence and significant security risks posed by CMCS vulnerabilities, underscoring the urgent need for improved isolation mechanisms in mini-program ecosystems.