Lost in Tokenization: Context as the Key to Unlocking Biomolecular Understanding in Scientific LLMs

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that providing scientific large language models with high-level structured bioinformatics context significantly improves biological reasoning, surpassing raw sequence input, and suggests a paradigm shift towards reasoning over expert knowledge.

Contribution

It introduces a novel approach of using structured bioinformatics context with Sci-LLMs, showing superior reasoning performance over sequence-based inputs.

Findings

Context-only input outperforms sequence-only and combined modes.

Raw sequences act as informational noise for models.

Reframes Sci-LLMs as reasoning engines over structured knowledge.

Abstract

Scientific Large Language Models (Sci-LLMs) have emerged as a promising frontier for accelerating biological discovery. However, these models face a fundamental challenge when processing raw biomolecular sequences: the tokenization dilemma. Whether treating sequences as a specialized language, risking the loss of functional motif information, or as a separate modality, introducing formidable alignment challenges, current strategies fundamentally limit their reasoning capacity. We challenge this sequence-centric paradigm by positing that a more effective strategy is to provide Sci-LLMs with high-level structured context derived from established bioinformatics tools, thereby bypassing the need to interpret low-level noisy sequence data directly. Through a systematic comparison of leading Sci-LLMs on biological reasoning tasks, we tested three input modes: sequence-only, context-only, and a combination of both. Our findings are striking: the context-only approach consistently and substantially outperforms all other modes. Even more revealing, the inclusion of the raw sequence alongside its high-level context consistently degrades performance, indicating that raw sequences act as informational noise, even for models with specialized tokenization schemes. These results suggest that the primary strength of existing Sci-LLMs lies not in their nascent ability to interpret biomolecular syntax from scratch, but in their profound capacity for reasoning over structured, human-readable knowledge. Therefore, we argue for reframing Sci-LLMs not as sequence decoders, but as powerful reasoning engines over expert knowledge. This work lays the foundation for a new class of hybrid scientific AI agents, repositioning the developmental focus from direct sequence interpretation towards high-level knowledge synthesis. The code is available at https://github.com/opendatalab-raiser/CoKE.