Comparing measures of the Hubble and BAO tensions in $\Lambda$CDM and possible solutions in $f(Q)$ gravity

TL;DR

This study evaluates various $f(Q)$ gravity models to address the Hubble tension, finding that an exponential $f(Q)$ model slightly reduces the tension but struggles with BAO data consistency, highlighting challenges in theoretical solutions.

Contribution

It introduces and tests specific $f(Q)$ gravity models against multiple datasets, assessing their ability to resolve the Hubble tension within a consistent theoretical framework.

Findings

Exponential $f(Q)$ model slightly reduces Hubble tension to 2.56σ.

Logarithmic and hyperbolic tangent models are inadequate.

Phenomenological models fit data but predict BAO distances exceeding observations.

Abstract

We test whether $f(Q)$ symmetric teleparallel gravity theories can solve the Hubble tension consistently with DESI DR2 BAO. We consider three $f(Q)$ functional forms: logarithmic, exponential, and hyperbolic tangent. We extend these models by allowing a cosmological constant, and compare to phenomenological models with a flexible exponential, hyperbolic secant, and polynomial decay addition to the standard $\Lambda$CDM $H(z)$. We test these models against DESI DR2 BAO, CMB ($Planck$ 2018 + SPT-3G + ACT DR6), local $H_0$, and Cosmic Chronometer data. The logarithmic and hyperbolic tangent $f(Q)$ models do not provide an adequate solution, but the exponential model does. Furthermore, it slightly reduces the $(\Omega_m, H_0 r_d)$ parameter space tension between CMB and BAO datasets to $2.56\sigma$, down from $2.65\sigma$ for $\Lambda$CDM. Although $\Lambda$CDM faces only $1.66\sigma$ tension in DESI data space, the $1\sigma$ higher tension in parameter space suggests a real anomaly. The models assisted by the cosmological constant perform slightly better still, at the cost of undermined theoretical motivation. They also perform poorly once local $H_0$ measurements are included. The phenomenological models fit all data reasonably well, yet the best-fitting models predict isotropically averaged BAO distances exceeding the DESI DR2 measurements at all redshifts. This highlights the difficulties of finding a theoretically motivated solution to the Hubble tension while remaining consistent with BAO data.