Spectra of composition operators on Paley-Wiener spaces and some consequences
Carlos F. \'Alvarez, O. R. Severiano

TL;DR
This paper thoroughly investigates the properties of bounded composition operators on Paley-Wiener spaces, including their spectrum, chaos, and stability, revealing detailed operator behavior in this functional analysis context.
Contribution
It provides comprehensive characterizations of composition operators on Paley-Wiener spaces regarding compactness, spectrum, chaos, and other dynamical properties, filling gaps in the understanding of these operators.
Findings
Complete characterization of compactness and spectrum
Identification of conditions for Li-Yorke chaos and positive expansivity
Results on positive shadowing property and Cesàro boundedness
Abstract
Bounded composition operators in Paley-Wiener spaces have simple forms, and they are just operators composed through affine mappings of the complex plane. The purpose of this article is to explore some notions about bounded operators and linear dynamics and provide complete answers for composition operators in Paley-Wiener spaces concerning compactness, spectrum, spectral radius, Li-Yorke chaos, positive expansivity, positive shadowing property, and absolute Ces\`aro boundedness.
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Spectra of composition operators on Paley-Wiener spaces and some consequences
C. F. Álvarez
Departamento de Matemáticas, Universidad del Atlántico, Cra 30 # 8-49 Puerto Colombia, Colombia
and
O. R. Severiano
IMECC, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, Brazil
Abstract.
Bounded composition operators in Paley-Wiener spaces have simple forms, and they are just operators composed through affine mappings of the complex plane. The purpose of this article is to explore some notions about bounded operators and linear dynamics and provide complete answers for composition operators in Paley-Wiener spaces concerning compactness, spectrum, spectral radius, Li-Yorke chaos, positive expansivity, positive shadowing property, and absolute Cesàro boundedness.
2020 Mathematics Subject Classification:
Primary 47A16, 47B33; Secondary 37D45
O.R. Severiano is a postdoctoral fellow at the Programa de Matemática and is supported by UNICAMP (Programa de Pesquisador de Pós-Doutorado PPPD)
1. Introduction
Let be a complex Hilbert space of analytic functions on a subset of the complex plane . If is an analytic self-map of , then the composition operator with symbol is defined by
[TABLE]
Operators of this type have been studied on a variety of spaces, such as Bergman, Dirichlet series, Hardy, Fock and Newton spaces [13, 15, 19, 21, 24, 26], and with special interest on the Hardy space of the open unit disk [15, 29]. As is well known in the literature, there are several basic questions in the study of composition operators: boundedness [15, 18], compactness [30], norms [11, 13, 15], spectra [15, 19], spectral radius [15, 18], normality [15, 19], complex symmetry [22, 23, 27, 28, 31], cyclicity [10, 20, 22, 28, 29], hypercyclicity [10, 20, 29], supercyclicity ( [14, 20], and more recently notions such as expansivity (and its variants), Li-Yorke chaos and the positive shadowing property [2, 7]. In many cases, it is difficult to solve these problems completely, and some remain open [16, 27].
For the Paley-Wiener space consists of all entire functions of exponential type less than or equal to whose restriction to belongs to Each space is a Hilbert space when endowed with the inner product
[TABLE]
Moreover, is a reproducing kernel Hilbert space which means the point evaluations of functions on are bounded linear functionals. Indeed, if and then where the reproducing kernel function is given by
[TABLE]
The sequence of kernels constitute a complete orthonormal set on For more information about these spaces, see the monographs [9, 12, 25, 32].
In [14], Chacón, Chacón, and Giménez initiated the study of composition operators on the classical Paley–Wiener space . They proved that is bounded on if and only if where with and , and as a consequence, showed that such operators are neither compact nor supercyclic. Similarly, on , the only bounded composition operators are those induced by symbols of the form where with and . In [22], Hai, Noor, and Severiano studied bounded composition operators on the full range of Paley-Wiener spaces , completely characterizing which of these operators are self-adjoint, unitary, normal, and complex symmetric [22, Proposition 3]. They also studied properties concerning linear dynamics such as cyclicity and supercyclicity, for instance, they extended [14, Theorem 2.7], showing that no Paley–Wiener space supports supercyclic bounded composition operators. While, the cyclicity of occurs if and only if and or with [22, Theorem 4].
In this article, we continue the study of composition operators on Paley-Wiener spaces . We show that certain properties of these operators, regarding boundedness and linear dynamics can be completely characterized. More precisely, we compute the spectrum and the spectral radius of each bounded composition operator on . Moreover, we completely characterize which of these operators are Li–Yorke chaotic, positively expansive, absolutely Cesàro bounded, and possess the positive shadowing property.
2. Preliminaries
2.1. Bounded composition operators on
The only bounded composition operators on are those induced by affine symbols of the form
[TABLE]
In this case, the adjoint of acts on reproducing kernels as follows for Since the only invertible bounded composition operators on occur when Moreover, Hai, Noor and Severiano [22, Proposition 3] showed that is normal on if and only if or and In particular, is unitary if and only if and
Let us denote by the -th iterate of where is as in (2.1), then a simple computation gives
[TABLE]
and Thus, we see from (2.2) that if and then is an attractive fixed point of , that is, pointwise as for all
2.2. Spectra of linear operators
Now we recall some basic definitions and facts from general spectral theory that will be used in the subsequent section. Let denote the space of all bounded linear operators on a Banach space The spectrum and spectral radius of are denoted by and respectively. It is well known that is determined by the spectral radius formula And as usual, denotes the unit circle
If the operators and are similar (resp. isometrically similar), i.e. there exists an invertible (resp. isometric invertible) operator such that then their spectra coincide. This is very useful for our purposes, since if is as in (2.1) with then we can write where and This allows us to obtain and hence
The next result was first proved in [14, page 2208] (and corrected in [22, Proposition 2.2]) and it shows that each bounded composition operator on is isometrically similar to a bounded weighted composition operator on
Proposition 2.1**.**
If where with and then the composition operator on is isometrically similar to the weighted composition operator on defined by
[TABLE]
where denotes a characteristic function. Moreover, we have
Hence, if with then is isometrically similar to the multiplication operator Therefore, and From the multiplication operator theory, we know that if is a continuous function essentially bounded then is a bounded operator on and This allows us to determine the spectrum and the norm of on each namely, and where denotes the imaginary part of the complex number
2.3. Notions in linear dynamics
Let us introduce some notions concerning linear dynamics that are relevant to our work. Such notions will be studied in subsequent sections.
Definition 2.2**.**
An operator is said to be hyperbolic if
The definition of a Li-Yorke chaotic operator that we use here is obtained from the equivalent statements of [4, Theorem 5].
Definition 2.3**.**
An operator is said to be Li-Yorke chaotic if there exists such that
[TABLE]
In this case, such vector is called an irregular vector for
In [4], Bermúdez et al. showed that if is a Li-Yorke operator then is neither normal nor hyperbolic.
Definition 2.4**.**
An operator is said to be positively expansive if for each with there exists such that
An alternative characterization for positively expansive operators was given by Bernardes et al. [6, Proposition 19], namely, is positively expansive if and only if for every non-zero vector the set is unbounded.
Definition 2.5**.**
Let
- (i)
*For we say that a sequence in is a *pseudotrajectory of if for all 2. (ii)
*We say that has the positive shadowing property if for every there exists such that every *pseudotrajectory of is -shadowed by an that is, there is such that for all
Bernardes et al. proved the following criterion for deciding whether a normal operator has the positive shadowing property [6, Theorem 30], let be a normal operator, then has the positive shadowing property if and only if is hyperbolic.
Definition 2.6**.**
An operator is said to be absolutely Cesàro bounded if there exists a constant such
[TABLE]
for all
We refer to [1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7] for more details on Li-Yorke chaotic, positively expansive (and its variants), absolutely Cesàro operator and to have the positive shadowing property.
3. Main results
3.1. Compactness
We know from [14, Corollary 2.5] that there no compact composition operator on Here we extend this result by showing that no Paley-Wiener space supports compact composition operators.
For we have when while
[TABLE]
when This helps us to show the following result.
Proposition 3.1**.**
There are no compact composition operators on
Proof.
If where with and then for all Let denote the normalized reproducing kernel by (3.1) we get
[TABLE]
Since tends weakly to zero and does not converge to zero in norm, it follows that is not compact. Therefore, also is not compact. ∎
3.2. Spectra and spectral radius
Let us consider the symbol where with and then can be written as follows
[TABLE]
where and This allows us to obtain If we also have
[TABLE]
where which gives us Since and are similar, this allows us to obtain properties of from .
Proposition 3.2**.**
If where with then is an isometry on Moreover, the spectrum of acting on is when
Proof.
Let If we have
[TABLE]
which shows that is an isometry. If we consider the auxiliary symbols and then For what we have done so far and since is unitary, we obtain
[TABLE]
which also shows that is an isometry.
Since is not invertible when and the spectrum of an isometry non-invertible operator is the closed unit disk, we obtain ∎
As a consequence we deal with the problem of identifying the bounded composition operators on with closed range and their spectra.
Corollary 3.3**.**
Each bounded composition operator on has closed range.
Proof.
Let where with and If then is invertible and hence has closed range. If then is similar to where Since closed range is preserved under similarity and has closed range on it follows that also has closed range. ∎
Corollary 3.4**.**
Let where with and Then the spectrum of acting on is
- (i)
* when * 2. (ii)
* when * 3. (iii)
* when *
Proof.
If we have that is the identity map and hence Hence for the polynomial we obtain Moreover, by spectral mapping theorem [17, Corollary 2.37], we have Thus if and only if or equivalently if If then is similar to (see (3.3)) and hence By Proposition 3.2, the result follows. If then is similar to the multiplication operator on and hence ∎
As a consequence of computing the spectrum, we obtain the following estimates.
Lemma 3.5**.**
If where with and then
[TABLE]
on . In particular, if then (3.4) is an equality.
Proof.
Since where and (see (3.3)), and we obtain which gives the upper estimate. The lower estimate follows directly from Corollary 3.4. ∎
Proposition 3.6**.**
If where with and then the spectral radius of on is
- (i)
* when * 2. (ii)
* when *
Proof.
If then is normal and hence Now assume By Lemma 3.5 and the formula of the -iterate established in (2.2), we obtain
[TABLE]
Letting go to infinity in (3.5), we get the equality ∎
3.3. Positive expansivity
Now we deal with the problem of identifying the bounded composition operators in that are positively expansive. Before proceeding, we need the following auxiliary results.
Lemma 3.7**.**
Let where If is a non-zero function then there exists such that for all
Proof.
By Proposition 2.1, there exists an isometric isomorphism such that Let be a non-zero function. Then also is non-zero function on Hence there exists a real number such that has positive measure. Now observe that
[TABLE]
If we obtain for all ∎
The following proof mimics the steps of the proof from [8, Lemma 3.2] , though we enclose it here for the sake of completeness.
Lemma 3.8**.**
If where with and then for each there exists such that for all sufficiently large
Proof.
For each we consider the auxiliary symbols and defined as follows
[TABLE]
then Let if is the zero function then the result is immediate. So we can assume that is not the zero function. By Proposition 3.2, we get Now we obtain a lower estimate for For each the Cauchy Schwarz inequality gives
[TABLE]
for all Since as we obtain as Let such that where Then for all sufficiently large we get If we obtain for all sufficiently large ∎
Proposition 3.9**.**
Let where with and . Then is positively expansive on if and only if or and
Proof.
We first assume In this case, is the identity map, and hence ( denotes the identity operator) and for all This allows us to obtain for all and all (see Lemma 3.5). Since is bounded for each , it follows from [6, Proposition 19] that is not positively expansive. If then Lemma 3.8 shows that for each there exists such that for all sufficiently large Since is not the zero function and as it follows that there exists sufficiently large such that Hence is positively expansive. Finally let If then is a unitary operator and hence is not positively expansive. If then by Lemma 3.7 for each non-zero function there exists such that for all Since as it follows that there exists sufficiently large such that and hence is positively expansive. ∎
3.4. Li-Yorke chaos
Now we study the existence of irregular vectors for bounded composition operators in and consequently the problem of identifying which theses operators are Li-Yorke chaotic.
Proposition 3.10**.**
No bounded composition on is Li-Yorke chaotic.
Proof.
Let where with and We have already seen that if then for all and all (see proof of Proposition 3.9). In this case, which implies that does not admit an irregular vector. Now assume By Lemma 3.8, for each there exists such that Since as and is not the zero function, it follows that for all sufficiently large In this case, and hence does not admit an irregular vector. If then is normal on and hence it is not Li-Yorke chaotic [4, Corollary 6]. ∎
3.5. Positive shadowing property
In order to characterize which bounded composition operators on have the positive shadowing property, we analyze the value of If then is normal and hence we can decide whether has the positive shadowing property from If then has a fixed point in Then we can proceed as the in proof of [2, Proposition 1] to decide whether has the positive shadowing property property.
Proposition 3.11**.**
No bounded composition operator on has the positive shadowing property.
Proof.
Let where with and If then is a normal operator on In this case, [6, Theorem 30] ensures that has the positive shadowing property if and only if is hyperbolic. By Corollary 3.4, is not hyperbolic. Therefore, does not have the positive shadowing property. Now assume then is the fixed point of in Choose such that For each the sequence defined as follows
[TABLE]
is a pseudotrajectory of Moreover, for all By Cauchy-Schwarz inequality, we get
[TABLE]
for every Taking in (3.6), we obtain which shows that cannot be -shadowed for any ∎
3.6. Absolutely Cesàro bounded
Finally, we study the notion of absolutely Cesàro bounded. As we will see below, the key to our studies are the estimates for norms obtained in Lemma 3.5 and the inequalities from Lemmas 3.7 and3.8.
Proposition 3.12**.**
Let where with and . Then is absolutely Cesàro bounded on if and only if or and
Proof.
If or and then by Lemma 3.5 we obtain for all and all In both cases we obtain
[TABLE]
Now we consider In this case, the sequence is unbounded. Moreover, Lemma 3.8 ensures that there exists such that for all sufficiently large Taking sufficiently large we get
[TABLE]
which implies
[TABLE]
Therefore, is not an absolutely Cesàro bounded operator. If and we use Lemma 3.7 and we argue as in the case to conclude that also is not an absolutely Cesàro bounded operator. ∎
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1[1] L. Abadias, A. Bonilla. Growth orders and ergodicity for absolutely Cesàro bounded operators. Linear Algebra Appl. 561 (2019), 253–267.
- 2[2] C. F. Álvarez, J. Henríquez-Amador. Dynamical properties for composition operators on H 2 ( ℂ + ) H^{2}(\mathbb{C}_{+}) . Bull. Braz. Math. Soc. 56 (2025), no. 1, Paper No. 10, 13 pp.
- 3[3] P. Bag, P. K. Das, H. Osaka, S Podder. Variants of expansivity in linear dynamics. Linear Algebra Appl. 720 (2025), 256–271.
- 4[4] T. Bermúdez, A. Bonilla, F. Martínez-Giménez, A. Peris. Li–Yorke and distributionally chaotic operators. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 373(1) (2011), 83-93.
- 5[5] N. B. Bernardes Jr, A. Bonilla, V. Müller, A. Peris, Li-Yorke chaos in linear dynamics. Ergodic Theory Dynam. Systems 35 (2015), no. 6, 1723–1745.
- 6[6] N. C. Bernardes Jr, P. R. Cirilo, U. B. Darji, A. Messadoudi, E. R. Pujals. Expansivity and shadowing in linear dynamics. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 461 (2018), no. 1, 796–816.
- 7[7] N.C. Bernardes Jr, U.B. Darji, B. Pires. Li-Yorke chaos for composition operators on L p L^{p} -spaces. Monatsh. Math. 191 (2020), no. 1, 13–35.
- 8[8] A. Blois, and O.R. Severiano. Dynamics for affine composition operators on weighted Bergman space of a half plane. ar Xiv preprint ar Xiv:2506.15822, 2025.
