Hallucinating with AI: AI Psychosis as Distributed Delusions

TL;DR

This paper explores how human-AI interactions can foster collective delusional thinking, likening AI hallucinations to psychosis within the framework of distributed cognition theory.

Contribution

It reframes AI hallucinations as a form of distributed delusional cognition, emphasizing the dual role of chatbots as cognitive tools and quasi-others influencing beliefs.

Findings

AI can reinforce and sustain delusional beliefs in users.

Chatbots serve as both cognitive artifacts and social partners.

AI interactions can lead to collective hallucinations in human-AI cognition.

Abstract

There is much discussion of the false outputs that generative AI systems such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, DeepSeek, and Grok create. In popular terminology, these have been dubbed AI hallucinations. However, deeming these AI outputs hallucinations is controversial, with many claiming this is a metaphorical misnomer. Nevertheless, in this paper, I argue that when viewed through the lens of distributed cognition theory, we can better see the dynamic and troubling ways in which inaccurate beliefs, distorted memories and self-narratives, and delusional thinking can emerge through human-AI interactions; examples of which are popularly being referred to as cases of AI psychosis. In such cases, I suggest we move away from thinking about how an AI system might hallucinate at us, by generating false outputs, to thinking about how, when we routinely rely on generative AI to help us think, remember, and narrate, we can come to hallucinate with AI. This can happen when AI introduces errors into the distributed cognitive process, but it can also happen when AI sustains, affirms, and elaborates on our own delusional thinking and self-narratives, such as in the case of Jaswant Singh Chail. I also examine how the conversational style of chatbots can lead them to play a dual-function, both as a cognitive artefact and a quasi-Other with whom we co-construct our beliefs, narratives, and our realities. It is this dual function, I suggest, that makes generative AI an unusual, and particularly seductive, case of distributed cognition.