The Status of the Astrophysical Parameters of Upper Main Sequence Stars

TL;DR

This paper compares different catalogues of upper main sequence stars to highlight the large discrepancies in key parameters like temperature and gravity, emphasizing the need for homogenized data for accurate stellar characterization.

Contribution

It provides a comparative analysis of stellar parameters from multiple catalogues, revealing significant inconsistencies and stressing the importance of data homogenization for astrophysical research.

Findings

Differences in $T_ ext{eff}$ can reach up to 10,000 K.

Differences in $ ext{log} g$ can reach up to 2 dex.

Current catalogues lack a homogeneous set of stellar parameters.

Abstract

Calibrating the ages, masses, and radii of stars on the upper main sequence depends heavily on accurate measurements of the effective temperature ($T_\mathrm{eff}$) and surface gravity ($\log g$). These parameters are difficult to obtain meticulously due to the nature of hot stars, which exhibit features such as rapid rotation, atomic diffusion, pulsation, and stellar winds. We compare the $T_\mathrm{eff}$, and $\log g$, values of apparent normal B-F stars in four recent catalogues that employ different methods and pipelines to obtain these parameters. We derived various statistical parameters to compare the differences between the catalogues and discussed the astrophysical implications of these differences. Our results show that the huge differences in $T_\mathrm{eff}$, (up to $10^4$\,K) and $\log g$, (up to 2 dex) between the catalogues have serious implications on the determination of ages, masses, and radii of the stars in question. We conclude that there appears to be no homogeneous set of stellar parameters on the upper main sequence, and one must be cautious when interpreting results obtained from using only one of the catalogues. The homogenisation of said parameters is an essential task for the future and will have a significant impact on astrophysical research dealing with stars on the upper main sequence.