Incorporating Naive Bayes Classification to Address Subpopulation Structure in Familial DNA Search

TL;DR

This paper introduces LRCLASS, a new likelihood ratio method that uses Naive Bayes classification to better account for population substructure in familial DNA searches, improving detection power.

Contribution

The study presents LRCLASS, integrating Naive Bayes classification into LR-based familial DNA analysis to address subpopulation effects, a novel approach in forensic genetics.

Findings

LRCLASS outperforms existing methods in detecting full-sibling relationships.

Naive Bayes and multinomial logistic regression classifiers show comparable performance.

The approach enhances the robustness of relationship inference under population substructure.

Abstract

Familial DNA search evaluates the genetic relatedness of two individuals by comparing the likelihood of their observed DNA profiles under two competing hypotheses-the null hypothesis that the individuals are unrelated and the alternative hypothesis that they are related-most commonly through the likelihood ratio (LR). Standard LR-based approaches typically assume a uniform genetic background; however, this assumption is rarely valid due to population substructure, where allele frequencies vary among subpopulations and can bias relationship inference. Existing modifications-such as LR calculations based on average allele frequencies (LRLAF) and strategies using maximum, minimum, or average likelihood ratios (LRMAX, LRMIN, LRAVG)-help mitigate these challenges but remain limited in their ability to fully address subpopulation differences. This study introduces a new LR-based statistic, LRCLASS, which incorporates a classification step using the Naive Bayes classifier to account for nuisance parameters associated with unknown subpopulation origins. In LRCLASS, the two DNA profiles being compared are jointly assigned to a subpopulation group via Naive Bayes before LR computation. Empirical evaluations using Thai population data show that LRCLASS achieves higher statistical power for detecting full-sibling relationships than existing LR-based methods. We further assessed multinomial logistic regression as an alternative classifier and found its performance comparable to that of Naive Bayes, suggesting flexibility in classifier choice. Overall, integrating the Naive Bayes classifier with LR computation offers a robust strategy for addressing population substructure in familial DNA search and highlights the broader potential of combining supervised learning techniques with forensic statistical methodologies to enhance the accuracy and reliability of genetic relationship testing.