Measuring Time Series Forecast Stability for Demand Planning

TL;DR

This paper emphasizes the importance of forecast stability in demand planning, analyzing how state-of-the-art models perform in terms of variance and proposing the need for further research on stability in production environments.

Contribution

It introduces a study measuring forecast stability alongside accuracy for advanced models and highlights the benefits of ensemble models in improving stability without sacrificing accuracy.

Findings

Ensemble models enhance forecast stability.

Forecast accuracy remains stable or improves with ensembles.

Stability is a crucial aspect for production deployment.

Abstract

Time series forecasting is a critical first step in generating demand plans for supply chains. Experiments on time series models typically focus on demonstrating improvements in forecast accuracy over existing/baseline solutions, quantified according to some accuracy metric. There is no doubt that forecast accuracy is important; however in production systems, demand planners often value consistency and stability over incremental accuracy improvements. Assuming that the inputs have not changed significantly, forecasts that vary drastically from one planning cycle to the next require high amounts of human intervention, which frustrates demand planners and can even cause them to lose trust in ML forecasting models. We study model-induced stochasticity, which quantifies the variance of a set of forecasts produced by a single model when the set of inputs is fixed. Models with lower variance are more stable. Recently the forecasting community has seen significant advances in forecast accuracy through the development of deep machine learning models for time series forecasting. We perform a case study measuring the stability and accuracy of state-of-the-art forecasting models (Chronos, DeepAR, PatchTST, Temporal Fusion Transformer, TiDE, and the AutoGluon best quality ensemble) on public data sets from the M5 competition and Favorita grocery sales. We show that ensemble models improve stability without significantly deteriorating (or even improving) forecast accuracy. While these results may not be surprising, the main point of this paper is to propose the need for further study of forecast stability for models that are being deployed in production systems.