Carbon Pricing in Traffic Networks

TL;DR

This paper analyzes how carbon pricing can steer traffic network flows towards emission targets, providing theoretical characterizations and algorithms for setting prices to achieve feasible emission budgets efficiently.

Contribution

It offers a comprehensive characterization of Wardrop equilibria under externality pricing, including algorithms for computing prices and flows that meet emission constraints.

Findings

Every feasible externality budget can be achieved as a Wardrop equilibrium with appropriate pricing.

For convex potential minimizers, prices can be derived as Lagrange multipliers.

An output-polynomial algorithm computes equilibria for single externality cases.

Abstract

Traffic is a significant source of global carbon emissions. In this paper, we study how carbon pricing can be used to guide traffic towards equilibria that respect given emission budgets. In particular, we consider a general multi-commodity flow model with flow-dependent externalities. These externalities may represent carbon emissions, entering a priced area, or the traversal of paths regulated by tradable credit schemes. We provide a complete characterization of all flows that can be attained as Wardrop equilibria when assigning a single price to each externality. More precisely, we show that every externality budget achievable by any feasible flow in the network can also be achieved as a Wardrop equilibrium by setting appropriate prices. For extremal and Pareto-minimal budgets, we show that there are prices such that all equilibria respect the budgets. Although the proofs of existence of these particular prices rely on fixed-point arguments and are non-constructive, we show that in the case where the equilibrium minimizes a convex potential, the prices can be obtained as Lagrange multipliers of a suitable convex program. In the case of a single externality, we prove that the total externality caused by the traffic flow is decreasing in the price. For increasing, continuous, and piecewise affine travel time functions with a single externality, we give an output-polynomial algorithm that computes all equilibria implementable by pricing the externality. Even though there are networks where the output size is exponential in the input size, we show that the minimal price obeying a given budget can be computed in polynomial time. This allows the efficient computation of the market price of tradable credit schemes. Overall, our results show that carbon pricing is a viable and (under mild assumptions) tractable approach to achieve all feasible emission goals in traffic networks.