On quantum creation of a toroidal universe

TL;DR

This paper investigates the quantum creation of a flat, toroidal universe, revealing that such creation involves singular instantons and cannot be described by semiclassical quantum gravity, challenging previous assumptions.

Contribution

It demonstrates that instantons for a toroidal universe are singular and argues that quantum creation from nothing is not feasible within semiclassical gravity.

Findings

Instantons are singular for toroidal universe creation.

The spacetime reduces to incomplete de Sitter space without quantum corrections.

Quantum creation of a toroidal universe likely depends on Planck-scale physics.

Abstract

We consider the quantum creation of a universe with flat spatial sections and the topology of a 3-torus, taking into account the effect of Casimir energy. We show that the corresponding instantons are singular. Since these instantons describe universes originating in a state of infinite energy, we argue that they cannot be interpreted as quantum creation from `nothing'. If quantum corrections to the energy-momentum tensor are neglected, the spacetime of the toroidal universe reduces to de Sitter space with appropriate periodic identifications. Contrary to previous claims in the literature, this spacetime is geodesically incomplete. We argue that this spacetime describes a classical universe originating at a singularity, and not a quantum origin. We conclude that the quantum creation of a toroidal universe from nothing cannot be described in the context of semiclassical quantum gravity -- it is either impossible, or it depends essentially on Planck-scale physics. We therefore see no reasonable way to compare the probability of creation of a toroidal universe, if it is possible at all, with that of a spherical universe.