Modelling the emergence of open-ended cultural evolution

TL;DR

This paper models how open-ended cultural evolution arises from the co-evolution of cultural systems and search spaces, emphasizing the importance of stochastic perturbations and selection-like processes for sustained resource production.

Contribution

It introduces a macro-level evolutionary model showing that open-ended cultural evolution requires co-evolution of cultural systems and search spaces with specific dynamic conditions.

Findings

Open-ended growth is rare and historically contingent.

Co-evolution of cultural systems and search spaces is essential.

Stochastic factors and selection-like processes must be balanced.

Abstract

Humans stand alone in terms of their potential to collectively and cumulatively change their culture in an open-ended manner. This open-endedness provides societies with the ability to continually expand their resources and to increase their capacity to store, transmit and process information at a collective-level. Here, we propose that the production of resources arises from the interaction between cultural systems (a society's repertoire of interdependent techniques, artifacts, norms and knowledge) and search spaces (an ensemble of needs, problems and goals facing a society). Starting from this premise we develop a macro-level model wherein both cultural systems and search spaces are subject to evolutionary dynamics. By manipulating the extent to which these dynamics are characterised by stochastic or selection-like processes, we demonstrate that open-ended growth is extremely rare, historically contingent and only possible when cultural systems and search spaces co-evolve. Here, stochastic factors must be strong enough to continually perturb the dynamics into a far-from-equilibrium state, whereas selection-like factors help maintain effectiveness and ensure the sustained production of resources. Only when this co-evolutionary dynamic maintains effective cultural systems, supports the ongoing expansion of the search space and leads to an increased provision of resources do we observe open-ended cultural evolution.