Do We Need Pre-Processing for Deep Learning Based Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography?

TL;DR

This study investigates whether deep learning models for ultrasound shear wave elastography require extensive pre-processing, finding that raw data can be effectively used, potentially simplifying and speeding up clinical elasticity assessments.

Contribution

The paper demonstrates that deep learning models can reliably predict tissue elasticity from raw ultrasound data, reducing reliance on traditional pre-processing steps.

Findings

Deep learning accurately differentiates elasticity groups with raw data.

Pre-processing slightly improves model performance but is not essential.

Deep learning offers faster, more reliable elasticity assessment.

Abstract

Estimating the elasticity of soft tissue can provide useful information for various diagnostic applications. Ultrasound shear wave elastography offers a non-invasive approach. However, its generalizability and standardization across different systems and processing pipelines remain limited. Considering the influence of image processing on ultrasound based diagnostics, recent literature has discussed the impact of different image processing steps on reliable and reproducible elasticity analysis. In this work, we investigate the need of ultrasound pre-processing steps for deep learning-based ultrasound shear wave elastography. We evaluate the performance of a 3D convolutional neural network in predicting shear wave velocities from spatio-temporal ultrasound images, studying different degrees of pre-processing on the input images, ranging from fully beamformed and filtered ultrasound images to raw radiofrequency data. We compare the predictions from our deep learning approach to a conventional time-of-flight method across four gelatin phantoms with different elasticity levels. Our results demonstrate statistically significant differences in the predicted shear wave velocity among all elasticity groups, regardless of the degree of pre-processing. Although pre-processing slightly improves performance metrics, our results show that the deep learning approach can reliably differentiate between elasticity groups using raw, unprocessed radiofrequency data. These results show that deep learning-based approaches could reduce the need for and the bias of traditional ultrasound pre-processing steps in ultrasound shear wave elastography, enabling faster and more reliable clinical elasticity assessments.