Weakly Supervised Virus Capsid Detection with Image-Level Annotations in Electron Microscopy Images
Hannah Kniesel, Leon Sick, Tristan Payer, Tim Bergner, Kavitha Shaga Devan, Clarissa Read, Paul Walther, Timo Ropinski

TL;DR
This paper introduces a weakly supervised virus capsid detection method in electron microscopy images that uses only image-level labels, reducing annotation effort while outperforming existing methods.
Contribution
It presents a novel weakly supervised detection algorithm that leverages pseudo-labels from a pre-trained model, eliminating the need for detailed bounding box annotations.
Findings
Pseudo-labels outperform other weak labeling methods.
Method surpasses ground truth labels when annotation time is limited.
Effective detection with minimal annotation effort.
Abstract
Current state-of-the-art methods for object detection rely on annotated bounding boxes of large data sets for training. However, obtaining such annotations is expensive and can require up to hundreds of hours of manual labor. This poses a challenge, especially since such annotations can only be provided by experts, as they require knowledge about the scientific domain. To tackle this challenge, we propose a domain-specific weakly supervised object detection algorithm that only relies on image-level annotations, which are significantly easier to acquire. Our method distills the knowledge of a pre-trained model, on the task of predicting the presence or absence of a virus in an image, to obtain a set of pseudo-labels that can be used to later train a state-of-the-art object detection model. To do so, we use an optimization approach with a shrinking receptive field to extract virus…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2024 poster
- the paper is well-written and easily to follow. - it proposed an relevantly simple but effective method for an impactful task. In their experimenst, aurthors sucessfully demonstrated the supriority over the consider baselines, includig supervised method as well as zero-shot learning with large scale pretrained models. - the authors utilized the spatial information and explored an novel way to refine the localization neural networks provide.
The proposed method has potential to work for not only electron microscope images but other medical images. It will be interesting and also brings broader impact if authors can provide discussions around this.
Overall, this work presents a very unique methodology and study design for curating bounding boxes in EM images. A contribution not emphasized in this work is the simplicity of the method, using a very intuitive heuristic that outperforms current unsupervised, deep learning-based detectors such as SAM and CUTLER. Though specific to EM, I believe the uniqueness and simplicity of this work would still be of interest to the computer vision community. The related work section is all comprehensive, a
- Though the related work section provides a comprehensive overview of current progress in WSOL methods, was there a reason why this work does not compare against other WSOL methods such as Xu et al. [1] (CREAM), Wei et al. [2] (ISIC), and other more recent works such as LOCATE [3] and GenPromp [4]? Though specific to EM, many other works in the WSOL domain can also be readily adapted. - In addition to lack of comparisons, one of the main limitations of this work that may prevent broader interes
1. The paper introduces a simple yet promising method for weakly supervised object detection. Meanwhile, it conducts extensive ablation studies to show that the proposed weakly supervised method can outperform other more fine-grained annotation-based approaches (e.g., bounding box and point annotations), given a certain time budget. 2. The paper designs a specific user study to demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of the proposed method.
1. In the experiments, the proposed method is not compared with other state-of-the-art weakly supervised learning methods, such as Zeng et al. 2019, Wei et al. 2022, and Lu et al. 2020. In addition, it is not compared with other CAM-based weakly supervised object detection methods in the experiments, such as Xu et al. 2022. Without a comparison with recent state of the art, it is difficult to determine the superiority of the proposed methods over other approaches. 2. The method requires the obj
Videos
Taxonomy
TopicsAdvanced Electron Microscopy Techniques and Applications · Cell Image Analysis Techniques · Image Processing Techniques and Applications
