Annotation-Free Human Sketch Quality Assessment

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, annotation-free method called GACL for assessing sketch quality by leveraging feature magnitude, validated through extensive human studies and applicable to image quality assessment and data re-weighting.

Contribution

It proposes GACL, a geometry-aware classification layer that quantifies sketch quality without human annotations and demonstrates its effectiveness across sketches, images, and data cleansing tasks.

Findings

GACL's feature magnitude correlates well with human quality perception.

GACL improves sketch recognition and quality assessment accuracy.

The method extends to natural images and data re-weighting applications.

Abstract

As lovely as bunnies are, your sketched version would probably not do them justice (Fig.~\ref{fig:intro}). This paper recognises this very problem and studies sketch quality assessment for the first time -- letting you find these badly drawn ones. Our key discovery lies in exploiting the magnitude ($L_2$ norm) of a sketch feature as a quantitative quality metric. We propose Geometry-Aware Classification Layer (GACL), a generic method that makes feature-magnitude-as-quality-metric possible and importantly does it without the need for specific quality annotations from humans. GACL sees feature magnitude and recognisability learning as a dual task, which can be simultaneously optimised under a neat cross-entropy classification loss with theoretic guarantee. This gives GACL a nice geometric interpretation (the better the quality, the easier the recognition), and makes it agnostic to both network architecture changes and the underlying sketch representation. Through a large scale human study of 160,000 \doublecheck{trials}, we confirm the agreement between our GACL-induced metric and human quality perception. We further demonstrate how such a quality assessment capability can for the first time enable three practical sketch applications. Interestingly, we show GACL not only works on abstract visual representations such as sketch but also extends well to natural images on the problem of image quality assessment (IQA). Last but not least, we spell out the general properties of GACL as general-purpose data re-weighting strategy and demonstrate its applications in vertical problems such as noisy label cleansing. Code will be made publicly available at github.com/yanglan0225/SketchX-Quantifying-Sketch-Quality.