On the interplay between plasma triangularity and micro-tearing turbulence

TL;DR

This study investigates how plasma triangularity influences micro-tearing turbulence in tokamaks, revealing that negative triangularity enhances micro-tearing modes and worsens transport, especially at high beta, while positive triangularity suppresses these modes.

Contribution

The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the effects of plasma triangularity on micro-tearing turbulence across multiple tokamaks using linear and nonlinear simulations, highlighting conditions that suppress or enhance turbulence.

Findings

Negative triangularity increases susceptibility to micro-tearing modes.

High beta and certain parameters lead to MTM-dominated turbulence in negative triangularity.

Spherical tokamaks near the MTM regime may experience worse transport at negative triangularity.

Abstract

In this work, we study the interplay between triangularity and micro-tearing turbulence using linear and nonlinear flux tube GENE simulations. We consider scenarios with negative and positive triangularity plasma shaping taken from existing tokamaks (TCV, DIII-D, MAST-U and SMART) and EU-DEMO. The study of all these tokamaks reveals a coherent picture. Negative triangularity geometry is more susceptible to micro-tearing modes (MTM), which, when present, make transport much worse than in positive triangularity. At sufficiently large $\beta$ (the ratio of plasma pressure over magnetic pressure), magnetic shear and ratio of electron to ion temperature gradient, all the scenarios with negative triangularity are dominated by MTM turbulence. In contrast, the corresponding scenarios with positive triangularity remain dominated by electrostatic turbulence and MTMs are subdominant or stable. We observe that conventional tokamaks usually operate in a parameter space far away from the onset of this MTM-dominated regime in negative triangularity, thus preserving the beneficial effect of negative triangularity on turbulent transport. In contrast, spherical tokamaks operate close to this regime and may ultimately exhibit worse transport at negative triangularity than positive triangularity. We find that lowering the magnetic shear in spherical tokamaks can preserve the beneficial effect of negative triangularity on electrostatic turbulence and prevent strong MTM transport. Finally, linear and nonlinear simulations reveal the reason for stronger MTMs: the magnetic drifts are faster in the negative triangularity geometry.