Stability theory for metal pad roll with consideration of viscous and magnetic damping

TL;DR

This paper develops a comprehensive theoretical model for metal pad roll instability in aluminium reduction cells, incorporating viscous and magnetic damping effects, and provides explicit formulas for stability thresholds and growth rates.

Contribution

It introduces the first analytical model that includes viscous and magnetic damping effects for metal pad roll instability, avoiding shallow-water approximation and considering capillary effects.

Findings

Derived explicit decay rates for damping effects

Provided analytical solutions for stability thresholds

Validated results against five independent studies

Abstract

We present a new theoretical model for the analytical prediction of the metal pad roll instability in idealised aluminium reduction cells consisting of two stably stratified liquid layers, which carry a vertical electric current and are exposed to a likewise vertical magnetic field. In contrast to the numerous previous models, we strive with this contribution for the most complete, and at the same time, a very approachable description of the linear metal pad roll instability. The model avoids the shallow-water approximation and incorporates some capillary effects, allowing it to be further applied to small-scale liquid metal batteries. As a major novelty the model also properly accounts for the stabilising effects of viscous and magnetic damping. To this end, we have derived explicit analytical formulae for the associated decay rates valid for arbitrary interfacial wave modes, which can also find application in other fields such as two-liquid sloshing. Our principal result is a set of explicit analytical solutions for stability thresholds and growth rates that are straightforward to implement and are intended to serve as theoretical benchmarks for multiphase magnetohydrodynamic solvers and model experiments. All of the results presented are carefully validated against five different and independent studies, with the particularity that we make use of quantitative stability threshold measurements for the first time.