Unlocking Surfactant Synergies for Fluorine Replacements: A Microfluidic Exploration of Emulsion Stability and Coalescence Dynamics

TL;DR

This study explores environmentally friendly surfactant mixtures using microfluidic techniques to analyze emulsion stability and coalescence dynamics, aiming to replace fluorinated surfactants in various applications.

Contribution

It introduces a novel microfluidic method to assess surfactant synergy and stability, demonstrating effective fluorine-free formulations with potential environmental benefits.

Findings

Surfactant mixtures show non-monotonic coalescence frequency trends.

Synergistic behavior observed between Glucopon 215 and Dow 502W.

Potential for pairing hydrocarbon and siloxane surfactants for stability.

Abstract

Fluorinated surfactants are widely utilized in various applications, including firefighting foams, coatings, and lubricants. Their wide utility is due to their unique properties, such as their ability to effectively lower surface/interfacial tension. However, the excessive use of fluorinated surfactants has raised environmental and health concerns due to their persistence in the environment and potential toxicity. The need for effective and sustainable surfactant replacements has therefore become critical. Our study investigates alternative surfactants mixtures that have been proposed to replicate the performance of traditional fluorinated surfactants, while minimizing environmental impact. Here, we study the stability of thin aqueous liquid bridges found in water in oil emulsions, with surfactant mixtures shown to provide synergistic fire suppression in fluorine-free fire fighting foams. Binary surfactant-water solutions of TritonX-100, Glucopon 215, Dow 502W were used, in addition to a ternary surfactant-surfactant-water mixtures of Glucopon 215 and Dow502W. Emulsion stability is assessed using a microfluidic device designed to measure the coalescence frequency. Coalescence frequency is measured as a function of total flow rate and surfactant concentration. A non-monotonic trend of coalescence frequency with flow rate is found for all the surfactants used. In addition, a non-dimensional frequency is introduced and is found to decrease with the Capillary number. The coalescence frequency of the surfactant mixture is found to be close to that of Dow502W, suggesting a synergistic behavior between Glucopon215 and Dow502W, even with less of the siloxane surfactant present in the formulation. This behavior highlights the potential for pairing slower hydrocarbon surfactants with faster siloxane surfactants to achieve an effective alternative stabilizing agent for fluorine free formulation.