An Objective Measure of Unsteadiness

TL;DR

This paper introduces a frame-independent measure of flow unsteadiness based on a variational principle, enabling better analysis of turbulent flows and vortex identification in fluid dynamics.

Contribution

It presents a novel, objective measure of unsteadiness derived from a variational principle and an objective vortex criterion, applicable to analytical and simulated flow data.

Findings

The measure is frame-independent and physically interpretable.

Application to Navier-Stokes solutions demonstrates effectiveness.

The new vortex criterion compares favorably with existing methods.

Abstract

Unsteadiness lies at the heart of turbulent fluid dynamics, eddy formation and instabilities in flows thus making it central to both understanding and controlling fluid systems. In this work, we present an objective measure for the unsteadiness of a time-dependent velocity field, the deformation unsteadiness, derived from a spatio-temporal variational principle, allowing for a frame-independent assessment of the unsteadiness of a given flow field. Additionally, as an application of our main result, we define an objective analogue of the classic $Q$-criterion based on extremizers of unsteadiness minimization. We apply our results to several examples of analytical flows as well as simulated flow data sets in two and three dimensions. In particular, we apply our newly derived vortex criterion to several explicit, time-dependent solutions of the Navier--Stokes equation and compare the results to existing vortex criteria. We give a physical interpretation of the deformation unsteadiness and discuss future research directions.