Uniting the World by Dividing it: Federated Maps to Enable Spatial Applications

TL;DR

This paper advocates for a federated spatial naming system to enhance scalability, privacy, and inclusivity in mapping for the Spatial Web, addressing limitations of centralized maps for indoor and outdoor applications.

Contribution

It introduces the concept of a federated mapping infrastructure, enabling multiple parties to manage and serve their own maps, thus improving scalability and privacy for spatial applications.

Findings

Federated maps improve scalability and privacy.

Existing services need re-architecture for federated maps.

Federated approach supports indoor and outdoor spatial applications.

Abstract

The emergence of the Spatial Web -- the Web where content is tied to real-world locations has the potential to improve and enable many applications such as augmented reality, navigation, robotics, and more. The Spatial Web is missing a key ingredient that is impeding its growth -- a spatial naming system to resolve real-world locations to names. Today's spatial naming systems are digital maps such as Google and Apple maps. These maps and the location-based services provided on top of these maps are primarily controlled by a few large corporations and mostly cover outdoor public spaces. Emerging classes of applications, such as persistent world-scale augmented reality, require detailed maps of both outdoor and indoor spaces. Existing centralized mapping infrastructures are proving insufficient for such applications because of the scale of cartography efforts required and the privacy of indoor map data. In this paper, we present a case for a federated spatial naming system, or in other words, a federated mapping infrastructure. This enables disparate parties to manage and serve their own maps of physical regions and unlocks scalability of map management, isolation and privacy of maps. Map-related services such as address-to-location mapping, location-based search, and routing needs re-architecting to work on federated maps. We discuss some essential services and practicalities of enabling these services.