Is Quantization a Deal-breaker? Empirical Insights from Large Code Models

TL;DR

This study investigates how quantization affects the quality of code generated by large models, finding that it preserves not only correctness but also important qualitative attributes like maintainability and simplicity.

Contribution

It provides empirical insights into the impact of quantization on qualitative aspects of code, extending beyond functional correctness in large code models.

Findings

Quantization preserves code correctness.

Quantization maintains code maintainability.

Quantization retains structural simplicity.

Abstract

The growing scale of large language models (LLMs) not only demands extensive computational resources but also raises environmental concerns due to their increasing carbon footprint. Model quantization emerges as an effective approach that can reduce the resource demands of LLMs by decreasing parameter precision without substantially affecting performance (e.g., 16 bit to 4 bit). While recent studies have established quantization as a promising approach for optimizing large code models (LCMs), a specialized subset of LLMs tailored for automated software engineering, their findings offer only limited insights into its practical implications. Specifically, current investigations focus only on the functional correctness of the code generated by quantized models, neglecting how quantization impacts critical aspects of code quality such as reliability, maintainability, and security. To bridge this gap, our study investigates the effects of quantization on the qualitative aspects of automatically generated code. We apply Activation-aware Weight Quantization (AWQ) to two widely used code models, CodeLlama and DeepSeekCoder, to generate Java and Python code. Using state-of-the-art static analysis tools, we evaluate software quality metrics and static features including cyclomatic complexity, cognitive complexity, and lines of code. Our findings reveal that quantization is a robust technique that not only preserves functional correctness, but also retains key qualitative code attributes sought after by developers, such as maintainability and structural simplicity.