ADIEE: Automatic Dataset Creation and Scorer for Instruction-Guided Image Editing Evaluation

TL;DR

ADIEE introduces a large-scale automated dataset and a fine-tuned scoring model for instruction-guided image editing evaluation, outperforming existing open-source models and enabling automated assessment and improvement of editing models.

Contribution

We developed ADIEE, a novel automated dataset creation method and a fine-tuned scoring model that significantly improves evaluation accuracy for instruction-guided image editing.

Findings

Outperforms all open-source VLMs and Gemini-Pro 1.5 on benchmarks.

Achieves a 17.24% increase in correlation with human ratings.

Boosts MagicBrush evaluation score by 8.98%.

Abstract

Recent advances in instruction-guided image editing underscore the need for effective automated evaluation. While Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have been explored as judges, open-source models struggle with alignment, and proprietary models lack transparency and cost efficiency. Additionally, no public training datasets exist to fine-tune open-source VLMs, only small benchmarks with diverse evaluation schemes. To address this, we introduce ADIEE, an automated dataset creation approach which is then used to train a scoring model for instruction-guided image editing evaluation. We generate a large-scale dataset with over 100K samples and use it to fine-tune a LLaVA-NeXT-8B model modified to decode a numeric score from a custom token. The resulting scorer outperforms all open-source VLMs and Gemini-Pro 1.5 across all benchmarks, achieving a 0.0696 (+17.24%) gain in score correlation with human ratings on AURORA-Bench, and improving pair-wise comparison accuracy by 4.03% (+7.21%) on GenAI-Bench and 4.75% (+9.35%) on AURORA-Bench, respectively, compared to the state-of-the-art. The scorer can act as a reward model, enabling automated best edit selection and model fine-tuning. Notably, the proposed scorer can boost MagicBrush model's average evaluation score on ImagenHub from 5.90 to 6.43 (+8.98%). Our code and models are available at https://github.com/SherryXTChen/ADIEE.git.