TL;DR
This paper introduces FNSDA, a Fourier space adaptation method enabling neural networks to generalize to new dynamical systems efficiently by adjusting Fourier modes conditioned on environment-specific parameters.
Contribution
The paper proposes a novel Fourier domain adaptation technique, FNSDA, that improves generalization to unseen dynamical systems with fewer parameters.
Findings
FNSDA outperforms existing methods in generalization performance.
FNSDA requires significantly fewer parameters.
FNSDA effectively adapts to four different dynamic system families.
Abstract
Learning the underlying dynamics from data with deep neural networks has shown remarkable potential in modeling various complex physical dynamics. However, current approaches are constrained in their ability to make reliable predictions in a specific domain and struggle with generalizing to unseen systems that are governed by the same general dynamics but differ in environmental characteristics. In this work, we formulate a parameter-efficient method, Fourier Neural Simulator for Dynamical Adaptation (FNSDA), that can readily generalize to new dynamics via adaptation in the Fourier space. Specifically, FNSDA identifies the shareable dynamics based on the known environments using an automatic partition in Fourier modes and learns to adjust the modes specific for each new environment by conditioning on low-dimensional latent systematic parameters for efficient generalization. We evaluate…
Peer Reviews
Decision·Submitted to ICLR 2024
Overall, the paper is fairly well written and relevant baselines are selected in the experimental section (which is fairly well conducted). It builds up upon FNO paper and (Kirchmeyer et al). Note that the proposition is conceptually close to the latter, adapting the model in the frequency domain whereas (Kirchmeyer et al) proposes an adaptation directly in the neural network parameters domain.
1. I would have enjoy at least experimental considerations showing the discrepancies in terms of Fourier frequencies in a dynamical when initial conditions or PDE coefficient vary. 2. Note that i believe that this can also be done more theoretically analysing the Fourier modes of some simple equations such as the wave equation. Such a work could be a nice motivation for the proposed approach 3. What are the main limitation of the work ? Do you know about systems that behave "no continuousl
The motivation of the proposed method is sound, and the research efforts in this direction can represent significant advancement of DL for dynamic system behavior modeling. The idea presented in the manuscript is novel, but intuitively makes sense. The paper does a good job explaining the ideas. The experimental results do provide some validation on the effectiveness of the proposed method.
The narrative of the paper can be further improved. The experimental results also can be further improved by more comprehensive test cases. See the questions section for more details.
- Interesting to perform adaptation mostly in the frequency domain. - The method seems to be well-trained and details on the influence of the different training improvements are presented. - Quantitative results are promising.
- The modification of the original FNO architecture is not very important. - There is no qualitative results presented (except Figure 1 which is not really commented). This is then hard to really capture if the model is able to generalize well. - It would be interesting to see the adaptation of the method with an increasing number of trajectories to adapt from. Currently, only-one shot adaptation is performed. - Adaptation is performed by updating $c_e$, it would be important to have an ablation
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
