Toward Sustainable Rare Earth Element Production: Key Challenges in Techno-Economic, Life Cycle, and Social Impact Assessment

TL;DR

This paper reviews the challenges in assessing the sustainability of rare earth element production, emphasizing issues in techno-economic, life cycle, and social impact analyses, and suggests future research directions.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive synthesis of existing sustainability assessments for REE production, highlighting key challenges and proposing future research pathways.

Findings

System scope varies widely in analyses.

Price volatility causes high uncertainty.

Current assessments are incomplete for decision-making.

Abstract

Rare earth elements (REEs) are 17 critical minerals used in many clean energy technologies like wind turbines and electric vehicles. Conventionally, we produce REEs from mining in few, geopolitically restricted regions. Developing systems that utilize new technologies and unconventional feedstocks provides an opportunity to meet increasing demand while improving sustainability. Techno-economic analysis (TEA), life cycle assessment (LCA), and social LCA (sLCA) are commonly used tools to assess the sustainability performance of these systems. However, analyses of REE systems encounter challenges including system scope, data availability, technology scale-up, and uncertainty. In the reviewed literature, systems served multiple functions beyond producing REEs, including circularizing production and waste remediation, leading to discrepancies in scope. Further, the instability of REE prices led to high uncertainty due to different revenue, costs, functional unit, and impact allocation. Therefore, these analyses leave decision makers with an incomplete understanding of the current landscape of REE production inhibiting intelligent and efficient identification of future direction. In this narrative review, we conducted a comprehensive overview of the literature, synthesized studies from each pillar of sustainability (economic, environmental, and social), highlighted the challenges and limitations in each field, and recommended direction for future work developing sustainable REE production systems.