Statistical Strong Lensing as a Test of Conformal Gravity

TL;DR

This study tests Conformal Gravity's predictions using strong gravitational lensing data, revealing that the universal parameter $oldsymbol{ extgamma^*}$ varies with stellar mass, challenging the assumption of its constancy.

Contribution

It introduces a novel analysis of strong lensing data to test Conformal Gravity, deriving a mass-dependent formula for $oldsymbol{ extgamma^*}$, contrasting with previous fixed-parameter models.

Findings

$oldsymbol{ extgamma^*}$ is larger than values from galaxy rotation curves.

$oldsymbol{ extgamma^*}$ decreases with increasing stellar mass.

Strong lensing data suggest $oldsymbol{ extgamma^*}$ is not a universal constant.

Abstract

As an alternative gravitational theory to General Relativity (GR), Conformal Gravity (CG) can be verified through astronomical observations. Currently, Mannheim and Kazanas have provided vacuum solutions for cosmological and local gravitational systems, and these solutions may resolve the dark matter and dark energy issues encountered in GR, making them particularly valuable. For static, spherically symmetric systems, CG predicts an additional linear potential generated by luminous matter in addition to the conventional Newtonian potential. This extra potential is expected to account for the observations of galaxies and galaxy clusters without the need of dark matter. It is characterized by the parameter $\gamma^*$, which corresponds to the linear potential generated by the unit of the solar mass, and it is thus a universal constant. The value of $\gamma^\ast$ was determined by fitting the rotation curve data of spiral galaxies. These predictions of CG should also be verified by the observations of strong gravitational lensing. In this study, building upon the previous research, we tested CG via strong lensing statistics. We used a well-defined sample that consisted of both galaxies and galaxy clusters. This allowed us to test CG through statistical strong lensing in a way similar to the conventional approach in GR. As anticipated, our results were consistent with previous studies, namely that the fitted $\gamma^*$ is much larger than that from rotation curves. Intriguingly, we further discovered that, in order to fit the strong lensing data of another sample, the value of $\gamma^*$ cannot be a constant, as is required in CG. Instead, we derived a formula for $\gamma^*$ as a function of the stellar mass $M_*$ of the galaxies or galaxy clusters. It was found that $\gamma^*$ decreases as $M_*$ increases.