The Emergence of Abstract Thought in Large Language Models Beyond Any Language

TL;DR

This paper reveals that large language models develop a small, critical set of language-agnostic parameters that underpin their ability to think abstractly across multiple languages, challenging the idea they operate solely in English.

Contribution

It identifies a core language-agnostic parameter space in LLMs and demonstrates how shared neurons support abstract thought beyond specific languages.

Findings

Development of a small, critical parameter subset essential for multilingual performance

Increase in shared neurons correlates with model development stages

Neuron-specific training improves multilingual generalization

Abstract

As large language models (LLMs) continue to advance, their capacity to function effectively across a diverse range of languages has shown marked improvement. Preliminary studies observe that the hidden activations of LLMs often resemble English, even when responding to non-English prompts. This has led to the widespread assumption that LLMs may "think" in English. However, more recent results showing strong multilingual performance, even surpassing English performance on specific tasks in other languages, challenge this view. In this work, we find that LLMs progressively develop a core language-agnostic parameter space-a remarkably small subset of parameters whose deactivation results in significant performance degradation across all languages. This compact yet critical set of parameters underlies the model's ability to generalize beyond individual languages, supporting the emergence of abstract thought that is not tied to any specific linguistic system. Specifically, we identify language-related neurons-those are consistently activated during the processing of particular languages, and categorize them as either shared (active across multiple languages) or exclusive (specific to one). As LLMs undergo continued development over time, we observe a marked increase in both the proportion and functional importance of shared neurons, while exclusive neurons progressively diminish in influence. These shared neurons constitute the backbone of the core language-agnostic parameter space, supporting the emergence of abstract thought. Motivated by these insights, we propose neuron-specific training strategies tailored to LLMs' language-agnostic levels at different development stages. Experiments across diverse LLM families support our approach.