Apparent motion of penumbral grains in a sunspot simulation

TL;DR

This study uses sunspot simulations to analyze penumbral grains, revealing how their physical properties and motions relate to magnetic field inclinations and turbulence effects.

Contribution

It provides detailed physical and statistical analysis of penumbral grains in a sunspot simulation, highlighting their magnetic and dynamic characteristics.

Findings

Penumbral grains show different magnetic inclinations based on motion direction.

Turbulence introduces randomness in the apparent motions of penumbral grains.

Magnetic field inclination varies with radial distance from the sunspot center.

Abstract

Context. The bright heads of penumbral filaments, penumbral grains (PGs), are manifestations of hot plasma flows rising to the surface. They are observed to move horizontally toward the sunspot umbra or away from it. Recent analyses of observations indicate that the direction of this motion is related to the inclination of the surrounding magnetic field. Aims. The penumbra of a sunspot simulated by the radiative magnetohydrodynamic code MURaM is analysed to get typical physical conditions in PGs, compare them to those in the surroundings, describe their spatial distribution, and study their evolution. Methods. We use time series of images that map intensity, temperature, magnetic field vector, and velocity vector in horizontal slices at the visible surface, in subsurface layers, and in vertical cuts through the simulation box to track PGs and compare, statistically and in individual cases, the physical quantities inside them with those in the surroundings. Results. The statistical analysis of simulation results provides average values of temperature, magnetic field strength and inclination, vertical velocity, and their changes with radial distance from the spot centre. We find a subtle difference between simulated PGs with opposite directions of motions when comparing the magnetic field inclinations inside and outside the PGs. The case studies, documented by movies, show that the differences of inclinations and the direction of motions may change during the lifetime of some PGs and that the turbulence in the surface layers introduces some randomness in the apparent motions of PGs.