Deriving physical parameters of unresolved star clusters. VIII. Limits of aperture photometry for star cluster studies

TL;DR

This study assesses the limits of aperture photometry for star cluster analysis, highlighting its accuracy constraints, especially for young clusters and the impact of viewing angles, and suggests alternative methods for certain cases.

Contribution

It systematically evaluates the accuracy and applicability limits of aperture photometry in star cluster studies using simulated data and provides guidelines for reliable parameter determination.

Findings

Aperture size larger than half-light radius improves parameter accuracy.

Young clusters (~10 Myr) are difficult to analyze with aperture photometry.

Viewing angle introduces up to 0.1 mag uncertainty in colour indices.

Abstract

Recently, it has been noticed that the discrepancies in the integrated colour indices (CIs) between star clusters and models are mostly due to the projection of bright stars in the apertures. In order to reduce this problem, the method of adaptive aperture photometry has been proposed. This method has been applied to star clusters from the M 31 Panchromatic Hubble Andromeda Treasury (PHAT) survey, and studies show that the adaptive aperture photometry performs better than the conventional approach. The aim of this study is to determine the best achievable limits on the accuracy and applicability of the aperture photometry method for studying star clusters in the local Universe. We computed a large network of artificial 3D star clusters spanning the parameter space of the M 31 clusters. We then simulated images of these clusters by projecting each onto a 2D plane from 100 directions. Star cluster images were generated in six passbands to match the PHAT survey. To investigate the limiting accuracy of aperture photometry and the limits of its applicability to star cluster studies, we measured the simulated images and performed parameter determination tests. We demonstrate that star clusters with and without post-main-sequence stars have significant photometric differences. We show that in order to obtain reliable physical parameters of star clusters, the CIs must be measured using an aperture with a radius larger than the cluster's half-light radius. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the parameter determination of young clusters (~10 Myr) is problematic regardless of the aperture size used. Therefore, it is advisable to determine the parameters of these clusters using colour-magnitude diagram fitting methods, when possible. We also show that the randomness of the viewing angle can lead to a CI uncertainty of up to 0.1 mag, depending on cluster parameters and aperture size.