SAP-Bench: Benchmarking Multimodal Large Language Models in Surgical Action Planning

TL;DR

This paper introduces SAP-Bench, a comprehensive dataset and benchmark for evaluating multimodal large language models in surgical action planning, emphasizing interpretability and safety in life-critical surgical decision-making.

Contribution

It presents SAP-Bench, a large-scale dataset with annotated surgical actions, and evaluates current models, highlighting gaps and proposing a framework for future research in surgical AI.

Findings

Current models show significant performance gaps in next action prediction.

The dataset enables detailed analysis of model capabilities in surgical contexts.

Evaluation reveals critical challenges in applying MLLMs to surgical planning.

Abstract

Effective evaluation is critical for driving advancements in MLLM research. The surgical action planning (SAP) task, which aims to generate future action sequences from visual inputs, demands precise and sophisticated analytical capabilities. Unlike mathematical reasoning, surgical decision-making operates in life-critical domains and requires meticulous, verifiable processes to ensure reliability and patient safety. This task demands the ability to distinguish between atomic visual actions and coordinate complex, long-horizon procedures, capabilities that are inadequately evaluated by current benchmarks. To address this gap, we introduce SAP-Bench, a large-scale, high-quality dataset designed to enable multimodal large language models (MLLMs) to perform interpretable surgical action planning. Our SAP-Bench benchmark, derived from the cholecystectomy procedures context with the mean duration of 1137.5s, and introduces temporally-grounded surgical action annotations, comprising the 1,226 clinically validated action clips (mean duration: 68.7s) capturing five fundamental surgical actions across 74 procedures. The dataset provides 1,152 strategically sampled current frames, each paired with the corresponding next action as multimodal analysis anchors. We propose the MLLM-SAP framework that leverages MLLMs to generate next action recommendations from the current surgical scene and natural language instructions, enhanced with injected surgical domain knowledge. To assess our dataset's effectiveness and the broader capabilities of current models, we evaluate seven state-of-the-art MLLMs (e.g., OpenAI-o1, GPT-4o, QwenVL2.5-72B, Claude-3.5-Sonnet, GeminiPro2.5, Step-1o, and GLM-4v) and reveal critical gaps in next action prediction performance.