Beyond Accuracy: Dissecting Mathematical Reasoning for LLMs Under Reinforcement Learning

TL;DR

This paper introduces SPARKLE, a detailed framework to analyze how reinforcement learning improves language models' reasoning, revealing that RL enhances internal strategy formulation and knowledge integration rather than external plan execution.

Contribution

The paper presents SPARKLE, a novel analytic framework for dissecting RL effects on language models' reasoning, and proposes SparkleRL-PSS for training with hard problems using partial scaffolding.

Findings

RL models are more robust to explicit plan degradation.

RL improves models' ability to integrate knowledge.

Hard problems with partial scaffolding can be effectively reused for training.

Abstract

Reinforcement learning (RL) has become the dominant paradigm for improving the performance of language models on complex reasoning tasks. Despite the substantial empirical gains demonstrated by RL-based training methods like GRPO, a granular understanding of why and how RL enhances performance is still lacking. To bridge this gap, we introduce SPARKLE, a fine-grained analytic framework to dissect the effects of RL across three key dimensions: (1) plan following and execution, (2) knowledge integration, and (3) chain of subproblems. Using this framework, we gain insights beyond mere accuracy. For instance, providing models with explicit human-crafted, step-by-step plans can surprisingly degrade performance on the most challenging benchmarks, yet RL-tuned models exhibit greater robustness, experiencing markedly smaller performance drops than base or SFT models. This suggests that RL may not primarily enhance the execution of external plans but rather empower models to formulate and follow internal strategies better suited to their reasoning processes. Conversely, we observe that RL enhances models' ability to integrate provided knowledge into their reasoning process, yielding consistent gains across diverse tasks. Finally, we study whether difficult problems -- those yielding no RL signals and mixed-quality reasoning traces -- can still be effectively used for training. We introduce SparkleRL-PSS, a multi-stage RL pipeline that reuses hard problems with partial step scaffolding, guiding exploration effectively without additional data generation. Together, our findings provide a principled foundation for understanding how RL shapes model behavior, offering practical insights for building more adaptive, data-efficient, and interpretable RL pipelines for reasoning tasks. Our code, data, and checkpoints are available at: https://sparkle-reasoning.github.io/.