The effect of measurement uncertainties on the inferred stability of planes of satellite galaxies

TL;DR

This study investigates how measurement uncertainties in satellite galaxy data affect the inferred stability of their planar structures, revealing that errors can significantly distort stability assessments.

Contribution

It systematically analyzes the impact of observational errors and host potential assumptions on satellite plane stability in Milky-Way-like galaxies.

Findings

Proper motion uncertainties cause linear increase in inferred plane width.

Gaia systematic errors significantly affect past width estimates.

Lower halo mass models show greater impact on stability analysis.

Abstract

Observations have revealed that the MW, Andromeda, Centaurus A (and potentially other galaxies) host spatially thin and kinematically coherent planes of satellites. Such structures are highly improbable within the standard LCDM cosmological model, and the dynamical stability of these planes has been a subject of debate for a long time. Accurately determining their stability requires a thorough understanding of orbital parameters such as proper motion, distance, and line-of-sight velocity, in addition to the gravitational potential of the host galaxy. However, many of these remain insufficiently constrained, leading to significant uncertainties in any analysis. This research aims to explore the impact of measurement errors in proper motions and distances of the satellite galaxies and in the adopted host halo mass on the inferred stability of satellite planes in Milky-Way-like potentials. Test satellite galaxies orbiting a host galaxy are simulated, mock observed by adding various degrees and types of observational errors, and then backward-integrated. Trends and correlations between the initial conditions and the applied uncertainties on the inferred orbital stability of the satellite systems are analyzed. Additionally, the effects of adopting incorrect potentials and the impact of different orbital eccentricities are considered. Uncertainties in proper motions lead to an inferred, ostensible widening of an intrinsically stable satellite plane, with its width increasing linearly with the adopted proper motion uncertainties. Even uncertainties on the level of Gaia systematics strongly affect the plane's inferred past width. Moreover, the potential with a low halo mass showed a significant impact on the stability of these planes, while the remaining two host models showed similar effects. Uncertainties in satellite distance also contribute noticeably to the inferred, apparent instability.