The role of the Lorentz force in sunspot equilibrium

TL;DR

This study investigates the influence of azimuthal magnetic field fluctuations on sunspot equilibrium, combining spectropolarimetric observations with magnetohydrodynamic simulations to demonstrate that sunspots maintain near-magnetohydrostatic equilibrium despite fine-structure variations.

Contribution

It provides the first detailed analysis of azimuthal magnetic fluctuations in sunspots, showing they do not disrupt overall equilibrium, supported by observational data and numerical simulations.

Findings

Magnetic and thermodynamic parameters vary with filamentary structures.

Lorentz force fluctuations correlate with plasma pressure and density variations.

Sunspots are close to magnetohydrostatic equilibrium despite fine-structure complexity.

Abstract

Sunspots survive on the solar surface for time-scales ranging from days to months. This requires them to be in an equilibrium involving magnetic fields and hydrodynamic forces. Unfortunately, theoretical models of sunspot equilibrium are very simplified as they assume that spots are static and possess a self-similar and axially symmetric magnetic field. These assumptions neglect the role of small scale variations of the magnetic field along the azimuthal direction produced by umbral dots, light bridges, penumbral filaments, and so forth. We aim at studying whether sunspot equilibrium is maintained once azimuthal fluctuations in the magnetic field, produced by the sunspot fine structure, are taken into account. To this end we apply the FIRTEZ Stokes inversion code to spectropolarimetric observations to infer the magnetic and thermodynamic parameters in two sunspots located at disk center and observed with two different instruments: one observed from the ground with the 1.5-meter German GREGOR Telescope and another with the Japanese spacecraft Hinode. We compare our results with three dimensional radiative magnetohydrodynamic simulations of a sunspot carried out with the MuRAM code. We infer clear variations in the gas pressure and density of the plasma directly related to fluctuations in the Lorentz force and associated with the filamentary structure in the penumbra. Similar results are obtained in the umbra despite its lack of observed filamentary structure. Results from the two observed sunspots are in excellent qualitative and quantitative agreement with the numerical simulations. Our results indicate that the magnetic topology of sunspots along the azimuthal direction is very close to magnetohydrostatic equilibrium, thereby helping to explain why sunspots are such long-lived structures capable of surviving on the solar surface for days or even full solar rotations.