SelfReflect: Can LLMs Communicate Their Internal Answer Distribution?

TL;DR

This paper introduces SelfReflect, a metric to evaluate if LLMs can transparently communicate their internal answer distributions, revealing their uncertainty levels and limitations in doing so.

Contribution

The paper develops the SelfReflect metric to measure LLMs' ability to faithfully summarize their internal uncertainty distributions.

Findings

LLMs generally cannot accurately reflect their internal uncertainties.

Sampling and refeeding outputs improves LLMs' ability to generate faithful uncertainty summaries.

SelfReflect provides a fine-grained measure of LLMs' transparency about their internal beliefs.

Abstract

The common approach to communicate a large language model's (LLM) uncertainty is to add a percentage number or a hedging word to its response. But is this all we can do? Instead of generating a single answer and then hedging it, an LLM that is fully transparent to the user needs to be able to reflect on its internal belief distribution and output a summary of all options it deems possible, and how likely they are. To test whether LLMs possess this capability, we develop the SelfReflect metric, an information-theoretic distance between a given summary and a distribution over answers. In interventional and human studies, we find that SelfReflect indicates even slight deviations, yielding a fine measure of faithfulness between a summary string and an LLM's actual internal distribution over answers. With SelfReflect, we make a resounding negative observation: modern LLMs are, across the board, incapable of revealing what they are uncertain about, neither through reasoning, nor chains-of-thoughts, nor explicit finetuning. However, we do find that LLMs are able to generate faithful summaries of their uncertainties if we help them by sampling multiple outputs and feeding them back into the context. This simple approach shines a light at the universal way of communicating LLM uncertainties whose future development the SelfReflect score enables. To support the development of this universal form of LLM uncertainties, we publish the code that implements our metric for arbitrary LLMs under https://github.com/apple/ml-selfreflect .