MergeBench: A Benchmark for Merging Domain-Specialized LLMs

TL;DR

MergeBench is a comprehensive evaluation suite for assessing the effectiveness of model merging techniques on large, domain-specific language models across multiple tasks, providing insights and guidelines for future research.

Contribution

The paper introduces MergeBench, a standardized benchmarking framework for large-scale model merging, covering multiple domains and evaluating various merging methods with extensive experiments.

Findings

Model merging performs better on stronger base models.

Techniques like coefficient tuning and sparsification improve knowledge retention.

Challenges include high computational costs and performance gaps.

Abstract

Model merging provides a scalable alternative to multi-task training by combining specialized finetuned models through parameter arithmetic, enabling efficient deployment without the need for joint training or access to all task data. While recent methods have shown promise, existing evaluations are limited in both model scale and task diversity, leaving open questions about their applicability to large, domain-specialized LLMs. To tackle the challenges, we introduce MergeBench, a comprehensive evaluation suite designed to assess model merging at scale. MergeBench builds on state-of-the-art open-source language models, including Llama and Gemma families at 2B to 9B scales, and covers five key domains: instruction following, mathematics, multilingual understanding, coding and safety. We standardize finetuning and evaluation protocols, and assess eight representative merging methods across multi-task performance, forgetting and runtime efficiency. Based on extensive experiments, we provide practical guidelines for algorithm selection and share insights showing that model merging tends to perform better on stronger base models, with techniques such as merging coefficient tuning and sparsification improving knowledge retention. However, several challenges remain, including the computational cost on large models, the gap for in-domain performance compared to multi-task models, and the underexplored role of model merging in standard LLM training pipelines. We hope MergeBench provides a foundation for future research to advance the understanding and practical application of model merging. Our project page is at \href{https://yifei-he.github.io/mergebench/}{https://yifei-he.github.io/mergebench/}.