Semiparametric Weighted Spline Regression (SWSR) in Confirmatory Clinical Trials with Time-Varying Placebo Effects

TL;DR

This paper introduces SWSR, a semiparametric spline regression method designed to accurately estimate treatment effects in clinical trials with time-varying placebo effects, ensuring error control and high power.

Contribution

The paper develops a novel semiparametric weighted spline regression approach to handle unknown temporal placebo effects in clinical trials, improving error control and robustness.

Findings

SWSR effectively controls type I error in simulations.

SWSR demonstrates high power in detecting treatment effects.

Case study confirms practical applicability of SWSR.

Abstract

In confirmatory Phase 3 clinical trials with recruitment over the years, the underlying placebo effect may follow an unknown temporal trend. Taking a clinical trial on Hidradenitis Suppurativa (HS) as an example, fluctuations or variabilities are common in HS-related endpoints, mainly due to the natural disease characteristics, variations of evaluation from different physicians, and standard of care evolvement. The adjustment of time-varying placebo effects receives some attention in adaptive clinical trials and platform trials, but is usually ignored in traditional non-adaptive designs. However, under the impact of such a time drift, some existing methods may not simultaneously control the type I error rate and achieve satisfactory power. In this article, we propose SWSR (Semiparametric Weighted Spline Regression) to estimate the treatment effect with B-splines to accommodate the time-varying placebo effects nonparametrically. Our method aims to achieve the following three objectives: a proper type I error rate control under varying settings, an overall high power to detect a potential treatment effect, and robustness to unknown time-varying placebo effects. Simulation studies and a case study provide supporting evidence. Those three key features make SWSR an appealing option to be pre-specified for practical confirmatory clinical trials. Supplemental materials, including the R code, additional simulation results and theoretical discussion, are available online.