Lower Bounds for Greedy Teaching Set Constructions

TL;DR

This paper investigates the limitations of greedy algorithms in constructing minimal teaching sets for concept classes, establishing lower bounds that suggest more complex methods are needed to achieve optimal bounds related to VC dimension.

Contribution

It provides the first lower bounds for greedy teaching set algorithms for small k, indicating their limitations and guiding future research towards more sophisticated approaches.

Findings

For k=1, greedy algorithms do not outperform halving bounds.

For k=2, the lower bound matches the known upper bound, confirming tightness.

Lower bounds extend up to k proportional to VC dimension, implying complexity in achieving optimal teaching sets.

Abstract

A fundamental open problem in learning theory is to characterize the best-case teaching dimension $\operatorname{TS}_{\min}$ of a concept class $\mathcal{C}$ with finite VC dimension $d$. Resolving this problem will, in particular, settle the conjectured upper bound on Recursive Teaching Dimension posed by [Simon and Zilles; COLT 2015]. Prior work used a natural greedy algorithm to construct teaching sets recursively, thereby proving upper bounds on $\operatorname{TS}_{\min}$, with the best known bound being $O(d^2)$ [Hu, Wu, Li, and Wang; COLT 2017]. In each iteration, this greedy algorithm chooses to add to the teaching set the $k$ labeled points that restrict the concept class the most. In this work, we prove lower bounds on the performance of this greedy approach for small $k$. Specifically, we show that for $k = 1$, the algorithm does not improve upon the halving-based bound of $O(\log(|\mathcal{C}|))$. Furthermore, for $k = 2$, we complement the upper bound of $O\left(\log(\log(|\mathcal{C}|))\right)$ from [Moran, Shpilka, Wigderson, and Yuhudayoff; FOCS 2015] with a matching lower bound. Most consequentially, our lower bound extends up to $k \le \lceil c d \rceil$ for small constant $c>0$: suggesting that studying higher-order interactions may be necessary to resolve the conjecture that $\operatorname{TS}_{\min} = O(d)$.