Excluding Stable Quark Matter: Insights from the QCD Vacuum Energy

TL;DR

This paper combines theoretical and data-driven approaches to accurately estimate the QCD vacuum energy, concluding that quark matter is not more stable than ordinary nuclei, thus excluding its existence as a stable form of matter.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive estimation of the QCD vacuum energy using multiple methods, clarifying the stability of quark matter relative to nuclei.

Findings

QCD vacuum energy estimated between (163 MeV)^4 and (190 MeV)^4

Quark matter is more than 100 MeV per baryon heavier than nucleons

Quark matter is not more stable than ordinary nuclei

Abstract

Quark matter (or quark nuggets), composed of quarks in the QCD deconfined and chiral-symmetry restored phase, has been conjectured to exist in nature for over half a century. With zero external pressure, it is stabilized by the balance between the quark Fermi pressure and the QCD vacuum pressure. Whether quark matter is more stable than ordinary nuclei has been a long-standing question, which requires understanding of the QCD vacuum energy. In this work, we employ both theoretical and data-driven methods to derive the QCD vacuum energy, utilizing the GMOR relation, the low-energy theorem, the equation of state from Lattice QCD, and the instanton gas/liquid model. The QCD vacuum energy is determined to be between $(163\,\mbox{MeV})^4$ and $(190\,\mbox{MeV})^4$. Alongside the quark matter pressure calculated from perturbative QCD calculations, both the 2-flavor (via Bodmer) and 2+1-flavor (via Witten) quark matter are found to be more than 100 MeV per baryon heavier than the nucleons. Therefore, we exclude the possibility of quark matter being a more stable state than ordinary nuclei.