Decoding the Issue Resolution Process in Practice via Issue Report Analysis: A Case Study of Firefox

TL;DR

This study investigates how Mozilla Firefox developers manage issue resolution by analyzing 356 issue reports, revealing common process patterns and providing insights to improve software maintenance practices.

Contribution

It offers a detailed analysis of real-world issue resolution sequences in Firefox, identifying 47 process patterns and their implications for software engineering.

Findings

Identified 47 common issue resolution patterns.

Analyzed process complexity and resolution times.

Provided insights for improving issue management.

Abstract

Effectively managing and resolving software issues is critical for maintaining and evolving software systems. Development teams often rely on issue trackers and issue reports to track and manage the work needed during issue resolution, ranging from issue reproduction and analysis to solution design, implementation, verification, and deployment. Despite the issue resolution process being generally known in the software engineering community as a sequential list of activities, it is unknown how developers implement this process in practice and how they discuss it in issue reports. This paper aims to enhance our understanding of the issue resolution process implemented in practice by analyzing the issue reports of Mozilla Firefox. We qualitatively and quantitatively analyzed the discussions found in 356 Firefox issue reports, to identify the sequences of stages that developers go through to address various software problems. We analyzed the sequences to identify the overall resolution process at Firefox and derived a catalog of 47 patterns that represent instances of the process. We analyzed the process and patterns across multiple dimensions, including pattern complexity, issue report types, problem categories, and issue resolution times, resulting in various insights about Mozilla's issue resolution process. We discuss these findings and their implications for different stakeholders on how to better assess and improve the issue resolution process.