Effect of Particle Shape on Stratification in Drying Films of Binary Colloidal Mixtures

TL;DR

This study investigates how particle shape influences auto-stratification in drying colloidal films, revealing that shape and surface area significantly affect particle distribution through diffusion and diffusiophoresis mechanisms.

Contribution

It introduces a unified framework incorporating particle shape and diffusiophoretic mobility to predict stratification in drying colloidal mixtures, supported by molecular dynamics simulations.

Findings

Solid spheres always enriched at the evaporation front when diffusiophoresis is suppressed.

Shape and surface area differences alter the dominance of diffusion or diffusiophoresis.

Mixtures of particles with similar surface areas show different stratification behavior.

Abstract

The role of particle shape in evaporation-induced auto-stratification in dispersed colloidal suspensions is explored with molecular dynamics simulations of mixtures of solid spheres, aspherical particles, and hollow spheres. A unified framework is proposed for the stratification phenomena in systems that feature size or shape dispersity on the basis of two processes: diffusion and diffusiophoresis. In general, diffusion favors the accumulation of particles that diffuse more slowly at the evaporation front. However, particles with larger surface areas have larger diffusiophoretic mobilities and are more likely to be driven away from the evaporation front by the concentration gradients of other particles with smaller surface areas. In the case of a bidisperse colloidal suspension containing small and large solid spheres studied in most of the work reported in the literature, the competition between the two leads to the so-called "small-on-top" stratification when the suspension is rapidly dried, as diffusiophoresis dominates near the interface. Here we employ a computational model of composite particles that mimics the Rouse model of polymers, where the diffusion coefficient of a particle is inversely proportional to its mass. For a mixture of solid spheres and aspherical particles or hollow spheres with similar masses, the diffusion contrast is reduced and the solid spheres are always enriched at the evaporation front, as they have the smallest surface area for a given mass and therefore the lowest diffusiophoretic mobility. The unified framework is further corroborated with a case study of a mixture of solid and hollow spheres having the same outer radius and thus the same surface area. In this case, the diffusiophoretic contrast is suppressed and the solid spheres, which have a larger mass and thus a smaller diffusion coefficient, are found to accumulate at the evaporation front.