Chronus: Understanding and Securing the Cutting-Edge Industry Solutions to DRAM Read Disturbance

TL;DR

This paper introduces Chronus, a novel DRAM read disturbance mitigation mechanism that significantly improves performance and security over existing methods like PRAC by addressing their key weaknesses.

Contribution

Chronus is a new on-DRAM-die mitigation mechanism that updates counters concurrently and dynamically controls refreshes to prevent wave attacks, outperforming PRAC and other solutions.

Findings

Chronus achieves near-zero overhead on modern DRAMs.

Chronus outperforms PRAC and other state-of-the-art solutions.

PRAC has significant performance overhead and vulnerability to wave attacks.

Abstract

We 1) present the first rigorous security, performance, energy, and cost analyses of the state-of-the-art on-DRAM-die read disturbance mitigation method, Per Row Activation Counting (PRAC) and 2) propose Chronus, a new mechanism that addresses PRAC's two major weaknesses. Our analysis shows that PRAC's system performance overhead on benign applications is non-negligible for modern DRAM chips and prohibitively large for future DRAM chips that are more vulnerable to read disturbance. We identify two weaknesses of PRAC that cause these overheads. First, PRAC increases critical DRAM access latency parameters due to the additional time required to increment activation counters. Second, PRAC performs a constant number of preventive refreshes at a time, making it vulnerable to an adversarial access pattern, known as the wave attack, and consequently requiring it to be configured for significantly smaller activation thresholds. To address PRAC's two weaknesses, we propose a new on-DRAM-die RowHammer mitigation mechanism, Chronus. Chronus 1) updates row activation counters concurrently while serving accesses by separating counters from the data and 2) prevents the wave attack by dynamically controlling the number of preventive refreshes performed. Our performance analysis shows that Chronus's system performance overhead is near-zero for modern DRAM chips and very low for future DRAM chips. Chronus outperforms three variants of PRAC and three other state-of-the-art read disturbance solutions. We discuss Chronus's and PRAC's implications for future systems and foreshadow future research directions. To aid future research, we open-source our Chronus implementation at https://github.com/CMU-SAFARI/Chronus.