Script&Shift: A Layered Interface Paradigm for Integrating Content Development and Rhetorical Strategy with LLM Writing Assistants

TL;DR

Script&Shift introduces a layered interface paradigm that aligns LLM capabilities with writers' intents, supporting diverse content development and rhetorical strategies to enhance creative control and natural writing flow.

Contribution

It presents a novel layered interface design that minimizes disruptions in AI-assisted writing by bridging different writing stages and strategies.

Findings

Enables creative and efficient use of LLMs in writing

Preserves natural flow of composition during AI-assisted editing

Supports diverse rhetorical strategies in content development

Abstract

Good writing is a dynamic process of knowledge transformation, where writers refine and evolve ideas through planning, translating, and reviewing. Generative AI-powered writing tools can enhance this process but may also disrupt the natural flow of writing, such as when using LLMs for complex tasks like restructuring content across different sections or creating smooth transitions. We introduce Script&Shift, a layered interface paradigm designed to minimize these disruptions by aligning writing intents with LLM capabilities to support diverse content development and rhetorical strategies. By bridging envisioning, semantic, and articulatory distances, Script&Shift's interactions allow writers to leverage LLMs for various content development tasks (scripting) and experiment with diverse organization strategies while tailoring their writing for different audiences (shifting). This approach preserves creative control while encouraging divergent and iterative writing. Our evaluation shows that Script&Shift enables writers to creatively and efficiently incorporate LLMs while preserving a natural flow of composition.